Summary of Alt Right and Right Wing Collectivism (Pt. 2) | Jeffrey Tucker | POLITICS | Rubin Report
In this segment of the Rubin Report, Jeffrey Tucker discusses the concept of right-wing collectivism, tracing its intellectual roots back over 200 years from Hegel to the post-war Nazi movement. He emphasizes that while many are familiar with left-wing collectivism, right-wing collectivism has been less understood, yet it has had a significant historical impact. Tucker highlights how Hegel's philosophy led to a belief in the supremacy of the state over the individual, paving the way for ideologies that prioritize nationalism and collectivism, which ultimately contributed to the rise of fascism.
Tucker references the intellectual lineage of right-wing thought, discussing figures like Frederick List, who advocated for protectionist trade policies, and Thomas Carlyle, who promoted the idea of the "great man" in history, arguing against the chaos of commercial society. He explores how this ideology evolved, incorporating elements of scientific racism and eugenics, particularly in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, leading to a resurgence of these ideas in contemporary politics.
He critiques the current sociopolitical landscape, suggesting that the left's contradictory stance on diversity and welfare state policies has created a fertile ground for the rise of identitarian movements and right-wing populism. Tucker argues that the alt-right is a manifestation of a broader illiberal ideology rooted in historical collectivism, characterized by a disdain for liberal values and a yearning for strong, centralized authority.
The conversation also touches on the emergence of Donald Trump and the alt-right, noting how the media's response to these movements has inadvertently fueled their growth. Tucker calls for a renewed commitment to liberal principles, advocating for an understanding of history that embraces the values of freedom and individual rights, while also celebrating diversity and human connection.
Tucker concludes by urging a shift in perspective, encouraging individuals to embrace a hopeful and joyful approach to life, which he believes can counteract the divisive narratives of both the left and the right.
Presenters/Contributors:
- Jeffrey Tucker
- Dave Rubin
Notable Quotes
— 14:36 — « Liberalism is a life in which we all benefit from each other's presence. We all just trade with each other. What kind of life is that where we all just are kind of the same and like each other and hope for backyard barbecues and baseball games? »
— 17:03 — « Through bloodshed comes life, and without bloodshed and death and violence and politics, then you're just going to live an irrelevant life. »
— 29:50 — « We have to celebrate the good life and the beautiful things and the things we love, the people we love, and the choices that we can make. »
Category
News and Commentary