Summary of Jemielniak: Gdula ma przekonanie, że PAN to leśne dziadki do zaorania
Summary of Discussion
In a discussion featuring Professor Dariusz Jemielniak, Vice-President of the Polish Academy of Sciences, the conversation revolves around the current state of Polish science and the government's role in its perceived decline. Jemielniak expresses concern over the lack of communication and cooperation between the scientific community and the Ministry of Science, particularly regarding recent reforms and changes to the Polish Academy of Sciences.
Key Points Discussed
- Critique of Government Actions: Jemielniak highlights a series of troubling incidents and reforms that have led to a deterioration of trust and effectiveness within Polish science. He mentions the replacement of experienced scientific authorities with less qualified individuals, which raises concerns about the future of research and innovation in Poland.
- Concerns Over Funding and Governance: The dialogue emphasizes that Polish scientific institutions, including the Academy, are chronically underfunded. Jemielniak argues that scientific institutes should receive funding on par with universities, suggesting that current funding models are arbitrary and inadequate.
- Artificial Intelligence Development: The discussion also touches on the importance of developing Artificial Intelligence capabilities in Poland. Jemielniak advocates for significant investment in this area, warning that without it, Poland risks falling behind in a critical technological field. He stresses the need for Poland to not just be a consumer of technology but to develop its own.
- Call for Change: Jemielniak calls for radical changes in the governance of Polish science, including a more collaborative and transparent approach from the Ministry of Science. He suggests that the scientific community needs to be involved in decision-making processes to ensure that reforms align with the actual needs of researchers.
- Concerns Over Talent Retention: The conversation reflects a broader concern about retaining talented scientists in Poland. Jemielniak notes that many young and skilled researchers are considering leaving the country due to the lack of support and opportunities, which could have long-term detrimental effects on the scientific landscape.
Overall, the discussion paints a picture of a scientific community in distress, grappling with government reforms that many perceive as harmful, while emphasizing the need for better funding, governance, and a focus on innovation to secure the future of Polish science.
Presenters/Contributors
- Professor Dariusz Jemielniak
- Professor Koźmiński
Notable Quotes
— 10:40 — « I think that Minister Wieczorek various cool things he will do, at least with academics. »
— 11:00 — « I don't know where he got this idea from, but that's what it looks like, he doesn't look like a forest grandfather. »
— 11:22 — « Meanwhile, the Ministry comes with solutions that are simply lopsided and tries to push them through by force. »
— 11:28 — « I think that in this particular case, the events that took place show that this Tandem does not work. »
— 23:05 — « It was a morning dose, a dose of utopia by Professor Dariusz Jemielniak. »
Category
News and Commentary