Summary of "Set Matrix Zeroes | O(1) Space Approach | Brute - Better - Optimal"

Summary of “Set Matrix Zeroes | O(1) Space Approach | Brute - Better - Optimal”

This video is a detailed tutorial on solving the “Set Matrix Zeroes” problem, a common interview question involving a matrix of 0s and 1s. The instructor explains three approaches:

• Brute Force
• Better (using extra space)
• Optimal (in-place with O(1) extra space)

The explanations include problem understanding, pitfalls, time and space complexity, and step-by-step algorithm development.

---

Problem Statement

• Given an N x M binary matrix (containing only 0s and 1s).
• For every zero in the matrix, set all elements in its row and column to zero.
• Important: Only the original zeros should trigger the zeroing; zeros introduced during the process should not cause further zeroing.

---

Approaches Covered

1. Brute Force Solution

• Idea: For every zero found, immediately set all elements in its row and column to zero.
• Problem: This approach fails because newly set zeros cause further zeroing, which is incorrect.
• Fix: Instead of directly setting elements to zero, mark them with a placeholder (e.g., -1) to indicate they should be zeroed later.

Steps:

1. Traverse the matrix.
2. When a zero is found, mark all non-zero elements in its row and column as -1.
3. After traversal, convert all -1s to zeros.

Complexity:

• Time: O(N * M * (N + M)) ≈ O(N³) in worst case.
• Space: O(1) (only uses the matrix itself for marking).

Drawback: Too slow for large matrices; interviewer will likely reject.

---

2. Better Solution (Using Extra Space)

• Idea: Avoid repeatedly scanning rows and columns by storing which rows and columns need to be zeroed.
• Method:
  • Use two arrays:
    • row[] of size N to mark rows that have zeros.
    • col[] of size M to mark columns that have zeros.
  • First pass: Traverse matrix, mark rows and columns that contain zeros.
  • Second pass: Traverse matrix again, set elements to zero if their row or column is marked.

Steps:

1. Initialize row[] and col[] with zeros.
2. Mark rows and columns on encountering zeros.
3. Update matrix based on marks.

Complexity:

• Time: O(N * M) (two passes).
• Space: O(N + M) due to extra arrays.

Drawback: Extra space usage may not be acceptable in interviews.

---

3. Optimal Solution (In-place with O(1) Extra Space)

• Idea: Use the first row and first column of the matrix itself to store the zeroing information, thus avoiding extra space.
• Key Insight:
  • First row marks columns to be zeroed.
  • First column marks rows to be zeroed.
  • Use a separate variable to track if the first column itself should be zeroed (since first cell overlaps).

Steps:

1. Use a variable col0 to track if first column should be zeroed.
2. Traverse matrix (except first row and first column):
   • If matrix[i][j] == 0, mark matrix[i][0] = 0 and matrix[0][j] = 0.
3. Traverse matrix again (except first row and column):
   • If matrix[i][0] == 0 or matrix[0][j] == 0, set matrix[i][j] = 0.
4. Finally, zero out first row and first column if needed.

Important Notes:

• The first row and column are used as markers.
• The order of zeroing matters to avoid overwriting markers prematurely.

Complexity:

• Time: O(N * M).
• Space: O(1).

This is the preferred solution in interviews.

---

Key Lessons and Concepts

• Directly modifying the matrix while scanning can lead to incorrect results due to propagation of newly introduced zeros.
• Using a placeholder value (like -1) can help delay modifications but is inefficient.
• Using auxiliary arrays to track rows and columns with zeros reduces time complexity but uses extra space.
• In-place marking using the first row and first column is an optimal space-saving technique.
• Careful handling of the first row and column is crucial to avoid marker collisions.
• The order of applying zeroes (bottom-up or top-down) matters to prevent premature overwriting.

---

Detailed Methodology / Instructions

Brute Force Approach

• For each zero found in matrix:
  • Mark all non-zero elements in the zero’s row and column as -1.
• After full traversal:
  • Convert all -1s to 0.

---

Better Approach

• Initialize two arrays row[] and col[] with zeros.
• Traverse matrix:
  • If matrix[i][j] == 0, set row[i] = 1 and col[j] = 1.
• Traverse matrix again:
  • If row[i] == 1 or col[j] == 1, set matrix[i][j] = 0.

---

Optimal Approach

• Initialize a variable col0 = 1 to track if first column needs zeroing.
• Traverse matrix:
  • If matrix[i][0] == 0, set col0 = 0.
  • For j from 1 to M-1:
    • If matrix[i][j] == 0, set matrix[i][0] = 0 and matrix[0][j] = 0.
• Traverse matrix in reverse order (to avoid overwriting markers):
  • For i from N-1 to 0:
    • For j from M-1 to 1:
      • If matrix[i][0] == 0 or matrix[0][j] == 0, set matrix[i][j] = 0.
    • If col0 == 0, set matrix[i][0] = 0.

---

Time and Space Complexities

Approach Time Complexity Space Complexity Brute Force O(N * M * (N + M)) ~ O(N³) O(1) (in-place) Better (Extra Space) O(N * M) O(N + M) Optimal (In-place) O(N * M) O(1)

---

Speakers / Sources

• The video features a single instructor who is the course creator and presenter.
• The instructor is associated with the stripers A2Z DSA course, a comprehensive Data Structures and Algorithms course.
• No other speakers or external sources are mentioned.

---

Additional Notes

• The video emphasizes understanding the problem constraints and carefully handling edge cases.
• It encourages coding the solutions to internalize the logic.
• The instructor also motivates viewers to subscribe and follow on social media for more content.
• Links to code implementations in C++, Java, and Python are mentioned to be available in the video description.

---

This summary captures the main ideas, step-by-step approaches, and lessons from the video on solving the “Set Matrix Zeroes” problem efficiently.

Category

Educational

Share this summary

Share on X/Twitter Share on Facebook Share on LinkedIn Share on Reddit Share on WhatsApp Share on Telegram

Video