Summary of Critical realism

Summary of Main Ideas on Critical Realism

Introduction to Critical Realism:
The video presents an overview of Critical Realism, primarily based on Roy Bhaskar's book "A Realist Theory of Science" (1975). It serves as a critique of positivism and the natural science view, positioning itself as a critical theory, distinct from postmodernism.
Objective vs. Subjective Reality:
Critical Realism acknowledges an Objective Reality that exists beyond human experiences. However, human understanding of this reality is mediated through subjective methodologies and perspectives. The theory aims to reconcile objective and subjective views of reality, emphasizing that all observations are influenced by the observer's methodological position.
Generative Mechanisms:
Critical Realism introduces the concept of Generative Mechanisms, which are the underlying forces or processes that produce observable phenomena. Examples include:
- Biological mechanisms (e.g., viruses causing flu symptoms).
- Social mechanisms (e.g., prejudice leading to discrimination).
The theory recognizes various mechanisms (physical, biological, social) that influence societal phenomena.
Social Structures and Agency:
The theory explores the relationship between Social Structures (which can enable or hinder social activities) and social agency (the capacity of individuals to make choices and enact change). Historical context is provided through examples of changing gender roles in parenting from the 1950s to modern times. The interplay between Social Structures and agency suggests that while structures condition behavior, individuals can also reshape these structures through their actions.
Application of Critical Realism:
The speaker expresses enthusiasm for applying Critical Realism in research, particularly in understanding issues like gender, poverty, and broader social problems.

Key Concepts Presented:

Objective Reality: Exists independently of human perception.
Subjective Understanding: Influenced by the observer's methodological position.
Generative Mechanisms: Underlying processes that drive observable phenomena.
Social Structures: Norms and expectations that shape social roles.
Social Agency: The capacity of individuals to influence Social Structures and norms.

Conclusion:

Critical Realism provides a framework for understanding the complexities of reality by integrating both objective and subjective perspectives, as well as recognizing the dynamic interaction between Social Structures and individual agency.

Speakers/Sources Featured:

The primary speaker is an unnamed individual discussing Critical Realism, referencing Roy Bhaskar's work.

Notable Quotes

— 05:39 — « It's a theory that tries to understand the complex links between social structures and social agency. »

— 09:21 — « Social structures are conditioning social activities, but at the same time it's true social activities and through our social agency that we also can transform social structures. »

— 10:35 — « It's a very fascinating Theory; it's a theory that I apply in my research in most cases. »