Summary of "CFA Level 1 Revision Lecture | Alternative Investments | CA Vikas Vohra | edZeb"
Summary of CFA Level 1 Revision Lecture on Alternative Investments by CA Vikas Vohra
Main Topics Covered
- Introduction to Alternative Investments
- Types of Alternative Investments
- Real Estate Investment
- Commodities Investment
- Infrastructure Investment
- Paintings and Antiques
- Hedge Funds (Hatch Funds) and Private Equity
- Investment Strategies within Hedge Funds
- Fee Structures in Hedge Funds
- Indexes and Measurement Challenges in Alternative Investments
1. Introduction to Alternative Investments
Alternative investments differ from traditional investments such as equity, fixed deposits, and bonds. While traditional investments are long-established methods (stocks, mutual funds, fixed deposits), alternatives include:
- Real estate
- Gold
- Cryptocurrencies
- Hedge funds
- Private equity
The primary purpose of investing in alternatives is not to earn extra money, but to diversify portfolios and reduce risk. Diversification benefits arise when the correlation between assets is less than +1.
2. Types of Alternative Investments (as per syllabus)
- Real Estate
- Hedge Funds (Hatch Funds)
- Private Equity Firms
- Infrastructure
- Paintings and Antiques
3. Real Estate Investment
- Types of properties: Residential and Commercial
- Investment forms:
- Private equity: Direct ownership (e.g., buying a house with family)
- Public equity: Buying shares of real estate companies (e.g., DLF, Shobha)
- REITs (Real Estate Investment Trusts): Listed entities owning real estate, providing liquidity and dividend income
REITs convert illiquid real estate into liquid shares, allowing easy buying and selling. Rental income from properties adjusts with inflation, providing inflation protection.
Challenges:
- Real estate returns are hard to estimate due to lack of transparency and prevalence of black money in India.
Real estate indexes:
- Appraisal Index: Based on estimated values; prone to under/overestimation
- Repeat Sales Index: Based on actual transactions; suffers from sample bias
- REIT Index: Nascent in India; more established in the US
4. Commodities Investment
- Examples: Gold, silver, crude oil, fertilizers
-
Ways to invest:
- Physical purchase (e.g., gold coins)
- Shares of companies involved in commodities (e.g., Titan for gold jewelry)
- Gold ETFs (digital form of gold investment)
- Futures and derivatives on exchanges like MCX
- Portfolio Management Services (PMS) for commodities
-
Gold Sovereign Bonds: Offer fixed interest plus gold price appreciation and tax advantages.
Sources of commodity returns:
- Change in spot price
- Interest or collateral income
- Rollover yield (costs/profits from extending futures contracts)
Benefits:
- Inflation hedge
- Diversification (negative correlation with equity)
Crude oil is the most traded commodity on MCX. Commodities are risky and volatile; hedging is commonly used by companies to manage input costs.
5. Infrastructure Investment
- Includes schools, hospitals, roads, telecom.
-
Investment modes:
- Direct (building and owning infrastructure)
- Indirect (buying shares of infrastructure companies)
-
Project classifications:
- Greenfield: New projects; riskier
- Brownfield: Existing projects/extensions; less risky
-
Master Limited Partnerships (MLPs): Common in the US but not yet in India.
- Infrastructure REITs are emerging to provide liquidity and easier transferability.
6. Paintings and Antiques
- Require specialized knowledge and incur high storage costs.
- Do not generate regular income; investment is mostly for capital appreciation and hobby.
- Suitable for very wealthy investors.
7. Hedge Funds (Hatch Funds) and Private Equity
- Hedge funds are structured as Limited Liability Partnerships (LLPs).
- Fund manager has unlimited liability, while investors’ liability is limited to their contribution.
- Hedge funds are lightly regulated compared to mutual funds.
- They can invest in a wide range of assets including real estate, derivatives, cryptocurrencies.
- Hedge funds can borrow money (leverage) and engage in short selling.
- Minimum investment is high (often ≥ 50 lakhs INR).
Fee structure:
- Management fee: Typically around 2% of Assets Under Management (AUM)
- Incentive fee: Typically 10-20% of profits
Fee calculation involves:
- Management fee charged irrespective of profits
- Incentive fee charged on profits above a hurdle rate
- Concepts of soft/hard hurdles and high water marks apply
Fund of funds invest in multiple hedge funds to diversify risk but charge additional fees.
8. Hedge Fund Investment Strategies
Event-Driven Strategies (4 types)
- Merger Arbitrage: Example - Bandhan Bank and Gru Finance merger
- Distressed Investing: Buying companies in trouble expecting turnaround (e.g., Ruchi Soya)
- Activist Shareholder: Investors pushing for management changes (e.g., ICICI Bank case)
- Special Situations: Investing based on corporate restructuring (e.g., Escorts Ltd divisions)
Equity Strategies (5 types)
- Fundamental Value: Buy undervalued stocks
- Fundamental Growth: Buy high growth stocks
- Quantitative/Technical: Chart-based trading
- Short Bias: Betting on price declines
- Market Neutral: Equal long and short positions
Macro Strategy
- Top-down approach analyzing sectors and economy before picking stocks.
9. Indexes and Measurement Challenges
-
Hedge fund indexes suffer from:
- Backfill bias (adding historical data after fund performance is known)
- Survivor bias (only successful funds remain in index)
- Self-selection bias (funds voluntarily report data)
-
Real estate indexes suffer from:
- Appraisal inaccuracies
- Sample bias
-
Commodity indexes: Reflect futures prices, which can distort actual spot returns.
10. Key Lessons and Exam Tips
- Alternative investments are mainly for diversification and risk reduction, not just higher returns.
- Understand the difference between private and public equity/debt investments.
- Know the structure, fee model, and risk profile of hedge funds.
- Be aware of various hedge fund strategies and their examples.
- Understand the challenges in measuring returns for real estate and hedge funds.
- Focus on definitions, examples, and fee calculation methodology for exam preparation.
Methodology / Instructions Highlighted
- For real estate: Distinguish between private/public equity, debt, and REITs.
- For commodities: Understand different investment methods (physical, ETFs, futures).
- For hedge funds:
- Calculate management and incentive fees stepwise.
- Apply hurdle rates and high water marks correctly.
- For investment strategies: Memorize key types and examples.
- For indexes: Recognize biases and limitations.
Speakers / Sources
- CA Vikas Vohra (Primary speaker and instructor)
- Students/participants (asking questions and interacting during the lecture)
This summary captures the core content, concepts, examples, and practical instructions presented in the lecture for CFA Level 1 candidates focusing on Alternative Investments.
Category
Educational
Share this summary
Is the summary off?
If you think the summary is inaccurate, you can reprocess it with the latest model.