Summary of PKn Diskusi P.11 (Keperawatan)

Main Ideas and Concepts

• Concept of Reality in Draft Criminal Law

  The principle of legality is emphasized, asserting that the law should be the main source for determining criminal acts. This includes both written laws and unwritten laws that reflect societal norms.

• Controversial Articles in the Draft Criminal Law
  • Articles 417 & 419: Criminalization of extramarital sex and cohabitation, raising concerns over personal freedoms amidst rising living costs.
  • Articles 251, 470, 471, & 472: Imposing penalties for abortion, including in cases of rape, which is viewed as insensitive to the trauma experienced by victims.
  • Articles 414 & 416: Fines for parents who display contraceptives in front of children, criticized for being overly punitive.
  • Article 278: Penalties for livestock roaming on private property, seen as a potential source of chaos.
  • Article 604: Minimal penalties for corruption, leading to protests over perceived leniency.
  • Article 604 regarding women: Fines for women stranded at night, raising concerns about discrimination.
• Student Protests

  The draft law has led to significant protests, particularly in Jakarta, where students express their dissatisfaction with the proposed legal changes.

• Proposed Solutions
  • The government should not intrude excessively into personal matters, such as adultery.
  • The need for protection of women involved in abortions, not just medical professionals.
  • Clarification on who is authorized to provide sex education.
  • Acknowledgment of existing laws that impose harsher penalties for corruption, advocating for consistency in legal consequences.
• Conclusion

  The group concludes that the Draft Criminal Law contains articles that do not align with Indonesia's democratic values and societal realities. The postponement of the law's ratification by the government is noted, but students continue to demand its cancellation rather than mere postponement.

Speakers

• Eva: Introduced the concept of legality in the Draft Criminal Law.
• Unnamed Sister: Discussed the controversial articles and student protests.
• Fitri: Presented potential solutions to the issues raised by the draft law.
• Agnes: Continued the discussion on solutions.

Notable Quotes

— 02:21 — « This caused another rebellion by various student groups. Thousands of students rebelled in front of the DPR building by carrying various posters and banners in the hope that this RUU KUHP will not be passed. »

— 04:50 — « This is a message because if left alone it will invite chaos. »

— 05:18 — « How can a corruptor not only be sentenced to 2 years in prison? »

— 06:42 — « The government should not interfere too deeply. »

— 09:46 — « Do not just draw bad conclusions, but we must take a different perspective. »

Category

Educational

Video