Summary of "Power, Politics & Media I Modi to Manmohan, Sonia to Rahul, An Insiders Account I Barkha Dutt"
The video features an in-depth interview with Sanjay Baru, former media advisor to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, discussing power dynamics, political leadership, and media in India from the UPA era to the present Modi government.
Key Points:
- Relationship with Manmohan Singh:
- Baru describes Singh as a mentor and partner rather than a friend.
- Despite some criticism in Baru’s book The Accidental Prime Minister, Singh’s leadership is largely endorsed (80%), with 20% criticism focused on his tolerance of interference, particularly from Sonia Gandhi.
- Singh’s decision not to contest the Lok Sabha elections in 2009 and remain in the Rajya Sabha was a turning point that diminished his political legitimacy and altered history.
- Baru recounts the complex power-sharing between Singh as Prime Minister and Sonia Gandhi as Congress President, noting that Sonia had significant influence on government policy, often via daily meetings, though not through direct access to official files.
- Congress Party Dynamics and Gandhi Family Influence:
- The dualism of power between the Prime Minister and Congress President has historical roots but remained contentious.
- Baru suggests that some officials had to seek Sonia Gandhi’s informal approval for key positions.
- He denies personal animosity from the Gandhis but acknowledges that his book and stance may have cost him a second stint in government.
- Modi Government and Political Shifts:
- Modi’s rise was facilitated by internal BJP power shifts and the vacuum created by UPA’s decline, especially between 2012-2014.
- Modi has transcended traditional party controls and has a solid core Hindu vote (~30%), but winning elections depends on capturing an additional 5-8% of the electorate.
- Modi’s government has strengthened India’s foreign policy stature, notably maintaining a balanced stance during the Ukraine crisis, which Baru terms “Narendra Modi’s Nehruvianism.”
- Baru acknowledges Modi’s economic reforms and international diplomacy but criticizes the increasing communalization of politics, particularly in northern India.
- Media and Political Communication:
- Manmohan Singh was a poor communicator politically, often earnest and professorial, unlike Modi, who connects directly with voters through social and traditional media.
- Baru highlights the paradox of Modi’s relationship with the media: bypassing traditional media channels while also fostering an environment of self-censorship and trolling.
- He discusses the decline of journalistic freedom due to self-censorship, fear of trolling, and corporate ownership of media, rather than overt government censorship alone.
- Baru defends some government interventions in media coverage for law and order reasons but warns against abusing power to silence dissent.
- India’s Democracy and Social Issues:
- Baru expresses concern over India’s declining reputation as a pluralistic democracy, citing increased caste and religious divisions.
- He stresses the importance of equality across caste and religions as foundational to India’s unity and democracy.
- The erosion of India’s composite culture and increasing communal tensions, exemplified by conflicts like in Manipur, worry him deeply.
- He calls for leadership that embraces India’s diversity rather than enforcing a narrow nationalism.
- Elite Politics and Social Change:
- Baru critiques the arrogance of the old Delhi elite (“Lutyens Delhi”) and praises Modi for challenging this entrenched power structure.
- However, he notes that many of Modi’s acolytes are now becoming the new elite, replicating the same behaviors they once criticized.
- Rahul Gandhi’s Bharat Jodo Yatra is seen as a political moment that helped him gain credibility by connecting with ordinary people and distancing from elite circles.
- Final Reflections:
- Baru would urge the Prime Minister to focus on reversing social divisions and reinforcing equality.
- To Rahul Gandhi and the opposition, his advice is to “hang on together” to remain relevant and challenge the ruling party.
- He emphasizes India’s strength in diversity and warns against ignoring it in favor of forced national unity.
- Baru underscores the importance of India maintaining its democratic values and pluralistic identity in the global arena.
Presenters/Contributors:
- Sanjay Baru (former media advisor to Manmohan Singh, author)
- Barkha Dutt (interviewer, journalist)
Category
News and Commentary
