Summary of "Fantasy Readers Advisory: Exploring New Worlds"

This video is a comprehensive presentation by Chrisy Chadwick, a consultant with the Massachusetts Library System and longtime Library Journal sci-fi/fantasy columnist, focusing on fantasy readers advisory and exploring the genre’s breadth, history, trends, and resources useful for librarians and readers alike.

Main Ideas and Concepts

1. Introduction to Fantasy

Fantasy is a subgenre of speculative fiction characterized primarily by the presence of magic or magical elements.
It often overlaps with other speculative genres like science fiction, horror, and mystery, but fantasy’s hallmark is magic and usually a secondary world (though contemporary fantasy is often Earth-based).
Superheroes straddle the line between fantasy and science fiction depending on the origin of their powers.

2. History and Evolution of Fantasy

Roots trace back to mythology and folklore, which form the foundation of many fantasy stories.
Modern fantasy began in the mid-to-late 19th century with works like Dracula, A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur’s Court, and early speculative fiction by H.G. Wells and Jules Verne.
The early 20th century saw growth in children’s fantasy and pulp magazines, which popularized fantasy short stories and serialized tales.
Mid-20th century introduced sword and sorcery, and high fantasy emerged strongly in the 1960s with authors like Ursula K. Le Guin.
Female authors began gaining prominence in the 1960s, though female-authored fantasy is often pigeonholed as young adult (YA).

3. Media Trends Influencing Fantasy

Fantasy is consumed across various media beyond books:
- Games: Tabletop RPGs like Dungeons & Dragons and collectible card games like Magic: The Gathering are popular entry points.
- Video Games: Role-playing games such as Final Fantasy and Zelda emphasize fantasy worlds.
- Movies: Major franchises like Harry Potter, Lord of the Rings, Pan’s Labyrinth, and Studio Ghibli films bring fantasy to wider audiences.
- Television: Series like Game of Thrones, Percy Jackson, and The Wheel of Time have expanded fantasy’s reach.
- Comics and Graphic Novels: Another format where fantasy thrives.

4. Publishing Landscape

Fantasy is published by major houses and imprints (e.g., Tor.com, Tor Books under Macmillan), but smaller presses also produce award-winning works.
Digital platforms like NetGalley and Edelweiss facilitate access to upcoming titles.
Print magazines have largely moved online, with many publishing short stories, poetry, and experimental works.
Specialized magazines like F&SF and F focus on underrepresented voices, such as Black authors in speculative fiction.

5. Fantasy Subgenres

High/Epic Fantasy: Set in secondary worlds, often involving sweeping quests (Rhythm of War by Brandon Sanderson).
Low Fantasy: Magical elements intrude on the real world or Earth-like settings (When Women Were Dragons).
Cozy Fantasy: Low stakes, character-driven, comforting narratives (Legends & Lattes).
Dystopian/Post-apocalyptic: Imagined suffering societies, overlapping with sci-fi (Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros).
Grimdark/Dark Fantasy: Gritty, morally complex, often violent or disturbing (Game of Thrones, The Poppy War).
Urban Fantasy: Set in modern cities with supernatural elements (Jim Butcher’s Dresden Files).
Gaslamp Fantasy: Victorian/Edwardian settings with magic and gothic elements (Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell).
Chinese Fantasy (Xianxia/Wuxia): Inspired by Chinese mythology and martial heroes (Jade City).
Fairy Tale and Myth Retellings: Classic stories reimagined from new perspectives (The Witch’s Heart).

6. Current Trends

Increase in duologies alongside traditional trilogies, often with novellas as part of series.
Rising popularity of fantasy romance (sometimes called “Romany”), blending romantic tropes with fantasy elements (Fake Mate).
Dragons as a major draw in fantasy since 2022, with numerous series focusing on dragon lore and relationships.
Genre blending is common, with fantasy intersecting with horror, romance, mystery, and more.

7. Readers Advisory Considerations

Appeal factors to consider when recommending fantasy:
- Plot pace: fast action vs. detailed world-building.
- Character types: heroic, morally gray, or complex.
- Setting: secondary worlds vs. contemporary Earth.
- Tone: cozy, light-hearted vs. grimdark, dark fantasy.
- Content warnings: blood, gore, death, etc. Websites like Did the Dog Die? help identify triggers.
Other formats