Summary of Comissão debate autorregulação e boas práticas no uso da IA no Brasil – 4/9/24

Summary of the 22nd Meeting

The 22nd meeting of Brazil's internal temporary committee on artificial intelligence focused on self-regulation and good practices in the use of AI, particularly in relation to Bill 2338/2023. The meeting featured public hearings with various experts and stakeholders discussing the implications and requirements of the proposed legislation.

Key Points Discussed:

• Purpose of the Meeting: The committee aims to refine Bill 2338, which regulates AI usage in Brazil. This involves incorporating feedback from public hearings to ensure the legislation is effective and protects citizens while fostering technological development.
• Self-Regulation and Good Practices: Emphasis was placed on the need for self-regulation within the AI sector to ensure ethical use and mitigate risks. Experts highlighted the importance of establishing clear guidelines for high-risk AI systems and promoting responsible innovation.
• Concerns About the Bill:
  • Human Rights: Experts expressed concerns that the current structure of the bill could create confusion regarding human rights protections related to AI, suggesting a more nuanced approach to defining high-risk AI applications.
  • Complexity and Clarity: There were calls for clearer definitions within the bill, especially regarding what constitutes high-risk AI and the obligations of developers. This includes ensuring that not all AI applications are classified as high-risk to avoid stifling innovation.
  • Regulatory Burdens: Some participants argued that the proposed obligations could impose excessive regulatory burdens on developers, particularly concerning documentation and assessments during the testing phase of AI systems.
• International Comparisons: The discussion included comparisons with European regulations, with some experts cautioning against directly copying these models without considering Brazil's unique context and needs. Suggestions were made to incorporate flexibility and adaptability in the legislation.
• Focus on Innovation: The need for the bill to promote innovation was stressed, suggesting that it should facilitate rather than hinder the development of AI technologies. There were calls for the legislation to support Brazil's competitiveness in the global AI landscape.
• Public Participation: Concerns were raised regarding the level of public participation in the legislative process. Experts urged for broader engagement to ensure that diverse voices are heard in shaping the AI law.
• Addressing Specific Issues: Various questions from the public highlighted concerns about AI's role in misinformation, privacy, and intellectual property rights. Experts reiterated that existing laws already address many of these issues, suggesting a focus on refining regulations rather than creating new ones.

The meeting concluded with a commitment to further refine the bill based on the discussions and expert contributions, aiming for a balanced approach that fosters innovation while ensuring ethical standards and protections for citizens.

Presenters and Contributors

• Senator Chico Rodrigues
• Senator Marcos Pontes
• Kurtney Lang, Vice President of Policy Trust Data and Technology, Information Technology Industry Council, USA
• Luí Fernando Prado, Lawyer and Guest Professor, Faculty of Law of Vitória, Brazil
• Mateus Risman, Director of Privacy and Data Policy, Information Policy Leadership Center, USA
• Ronaldo Lemos, Director, Institute of Technology and Society, Brazil
• Cristina Aires Correa Lima de Siqueira Dias, Specialist Lawyer, National Confederation of Industry (CNI), Brazil

Notable Quotes

— 04:28 — « If we are not careful with the main text, it runs the risk of becoming obsolete minutes after being promulgated. »

— 06:10 — « The sky's the limit and no one knows where the sky's the limit. »

— 50:45 — « If the bill were a football team, it would be as if we were only talking about defenders. »

— 61:40 — « No wind helps those who don't know which port they are sailing towards. »

Category

News and Commentary

Video