[최강1교시] Full.ver 일리아스와 오디세이아 I 서양 고전학자 김헌

Main ideas, concepts, and lessons

• Purpose of the lecture

  • Introduce Kim Heon, a scholar of Greek and Roman classics, and frame the topic as the roots of Greek/Roman mythology.
  • The lecture focuses on two Western foundational epics:
    • The Iliad (Greek: Elias in subtitles)
    • *The Odyssey
  • A key claim is presented early: the epic tradition is foundational to later “great literature,” especially through models set by the Iliad and the Odyssey.

• Valuing the epics

  • A French poet/novelist (named as Lemon Knot in subtitles—unclear due to subtitle errors) is cited:
    • “All great literature is either ‘Iliad’ or ‘Odyssey.’”
  • Interpretation:
    • Major Western works were created by using the Iliad and Odyssey as models.

• Historical backdrop: Mycenae, Trojan War, and the “Dark Age”

  • Minoan civilization (Crete) declines → Mycenaean civilization centered on Mycenae.
  • The Trojan War is placed near the end of the Mycenaean era.
  • A contrast is drawn between:
    • Homeric-scale Greek forces (the lecture gives “about 100,” described as ~10× allied force size—likely a garbled statistic).
  • After Greek victory:
    • Greeks enter a “Dark Age” due to internal turmoil, exhaustion, monarchs leaving to fight, and Dorian invasion (portrayed as warlike and violent).
  • Around the 8th century BCE, Greece regroups.
  • Homer is placed as active around the beginning of the “ancient period.”
  • The Phoenician alphabet is said to have been introduced to Greece, and Greeks adapted it.
  • Homer is described as composing the epics by adding imagination/creativity to oral Trojan War traditions.

---

Method / structure presented (epic composition and narrative progression)

• How to understand the Trojan War chronologically (as presented by surviving works)
  • Early material:
    • Cypria (early part; subtitles indicate it begins the sequence)
  • Then the Iliad:
    • Covers the last year, focusing on roughly 50 days
  • Followed by:
    • Aethiopis
    • Little Iliad
    • The Fall of Ilion (the fall of Troy)
  • Then Odyssey-related continuation:
    • The Return of the Heroes (Greek heroes return)
    • The Odyssey, focusing especially on Odysseus, whose return takes 10 years

---

The Iliad: main story concepts and the “wrath” theme

1) Core theme: “wrath” (Achilles’ wrath)

• The lecture emphasizes that The Iliad begins with a single first word:
  • “Wrath”
• This “wrath” is presented as:
  • The theme of the whole Iliad
  • Beginning with Achilles’ wrath toward Agamemnon, after Agamemnon dishonors him.

2) Opening conflict and escalation (step-by-step narrative)

• Priest Chryses (Apollo’s priest) asks Agamemnon to return his daughter:
  • Chryses offers a large ransom to get back Chryseis.
  • Agamemnon refuses because Chryseis is Agamemnon’s war prize, tied to honor.
• Apollo punishes the Greeks:
  • Chryses prays to Apollo.
  • Apollo shoots arrows at the Greek army, killing soldiers without a formal battle.
• Achilles convenes a council:
  • Achilles urges Agamemnon to restore order by returning Chryseis.
• Agamemnon returns Chryseis but takes another prize:
  • Agamemnon cannot accept losing his honor.
  • He seizes Briseis from Achilles.
• First “wrath” intensifies:
  • Achilles is enraged and draws a sword to attack Agamemnon.
  • Athena intervenes, stopping Achilles from killing him.
  • Achilles endures humiliation but continues insulting Agamemnon.
• Achilles withdraws from war:
  • He argues the war’s real motive is Helena and questions why he should shed blood for Agamemnon.
• Greek collapse and Achilles’ responsibility:
  • With Achilles gone, the Greeks suffer and are pushed back.
  • Agamemnon sends envoys—Odysseus, Phoenix, Ajax—to apologize and offer restitution (including returning Briseis).
  • Achilles still refuses; his anger must “suffer more” first.

3) Patroclus’ death: wrath causes the tragic reversal

• Trojan pressure becomes critical:
  • Hector nearly destroys the Greeks.
• Patroclus persuades Achilles’ choice:
  • Patroclus is moved by the crisis.
  • Achilles permits Patroclus to fight in his place.
• Patroclus wears Achilles’ armor:
  • He uses Achilles’ gear to drive the Trojans back.
• Patroclus kills, advances—then dies:
  • Hector ultimately confronts Patroclus and kills him.
  • Paradox emphasized: Achilles’ attempt to make others regret betrayal results in Achilles’ closest friend dying due to Achilles’ wrath-driven absence.

4) Achilles’ second wrath and heroic climax

• Achilles learns of Patroclus’ death:
  • He becomes grief-stricken and furious.
  • Framed as Achilles’ second wrath.
• Need for armor and divine support
  • Achilles cannot fight immediately because the armor situation is complicated (the enemy has it).
  • Thetis arranges new armor via Hephaestus.
• Climactic battle: Achilles vs. Hector
  • Hector had worn Achilles’ armor earlier; Achilles fights in newly made armor.
  • The lecture describes it as two “Achilles” identities competing (armor symbolism).
• Achilles humiliates the corpse
  • After victory, Achilles strips Hector’s armor, ties him to his chariot, and drags him around Troy multiple times.
  • Women in Troy grieve as Hector’s humiliation unfolds.

5) Divine intervention and the “funeral ending” lesson

• Achilles’ rage becomes excessive:
  • The gods criticize him for degrading Hector beyond reason.
• Zeus orders submission:
  • Zeus commands Thetis to tell Achilles to release Hector’s body and end the vengeance.
• Final scene (“funeral ending”)
  • Night falls.
  • Priam visits Achilles.
  • They meet not as armed enemies but as grieving fathers/men.
  • Achilles returns Hector’s body.
  • Hector receives funeral rites.
• The Iliad is framed as:
  • Beginning with wrath
  • Ending in death/funeral
• Hidden message
  • Even heroic violence fueled by honor ends in death.
  • Everyone’s fate converges: humans cannot escape mortality.

6) After the Iliad: how Troy is finally captured

• Later events are summarized:
  • Achilles eventually dies (the lecture mentions an arrow to his heel).
  • Troy falls via the Trojan Horse:
    • Greeks pretend to leave, leaving a wooden horse.
    • Trojans bring it inside Troy.
    • At midnight, Greeks inside escape, open gates, and defeat the Trojans.
• Return of heroes
  • Other heroes return home, but Odysseus is away longest—setting up the Odyssey.

---

The Odyssey: main story concepts and the “name” theme

1) A striking difference in how the protagonist is presented

• In the Iliad, the protagonist Achilles is named immediately.
• In the Odyssey, the opening describes the protagonist as:
  • “a person/man” (name withheld)
• Lecture interpretation:
  • The story is of Odysseus, whose name is hidden, eventually revealed/recovered.
  • The withheld-name motif symbolizes a larger identity/being reclaimed theme.

2) Structure of early Odysseus absence (Books 1–4)

• Odysseus does not appear early.
• Early books focus on:
  • Ithaca, Penelope’s waiting for 20 years
  • Telemachus, her son, waiting for his father

3) Calypso: paradise that is still “hiding”

• Odysseus reaches an island ruled by Calypso.
• Calypso is described as living like a paradise among fairies; Odysseus stays seven years.
• Key symbolic interpretation:
  • Calypso’s name means “one who covers/hides.”
  • Odysseus becomes “hidden,” concealed from the world.
• Turning point:
  • Calypso offers nectar and ambrosia (immortality).
  • Odysseus refuses eternal godhood and chooses to return home as a mortal.
• Rationale suggested:
  • loyalty to Penelope and Telemachus
  • preference for human finitude over endless divine life
  • escaping “forgotten existence” and reclaiming identity

4) Arrival at King Alcinous’ kingdom: “reveal the name” moment

• Odysseus reaches the realm of King Alcinous.
• He meets Princess Nausicaa (Naoshika in subtitles).
• At a feast, Demodocus sings about the Trojan Horse.
• Odysseus breaks into tears.
• Alcinous asks:
  • why Odysseus is crying
  • what his name is
• Odysseus finally reveals his identity:
  • “Odysseus” (the first full disclosure after being hidden)

5) Polyphemus episode: “Nobody” trick and restored identity

• Odysseus encounters Polyphemus, a one-eyed giant (on Sicily).
• He is trapped and companions are eaten one by one.
• Escape strategy (step-by-step):
  • Odysseus feeds Polyphemus sweet wine
  • Polyphemus asks for his name
  • Odysseus answers with a trick: “Nobody” (Greek “Outis,” translated as Nobody)
• When Polyphemus is blinded:
  • Polyphemus asks for help and says “Nobody” did it.
  • Other Cyclopes conclude he must be cursed by the gods (since “nobody” attacked him).
  • Odysseus escapes by ship.
• Identity-reveal beat:
  • Odysseus taunts Polyphemus and announces himself as Odysseus again.

6) Poseidon’s torment and Odysseus’ long suffering

• Polyphemus is identified as the son of Poseidon.
• Poseidon torments Odysseus after the blinding.
• Odysseus endures sea hardships, loses companions, is imprisoned by Calypso for seven years, and later reaches Alcinous’ palace.
• Gods—especially Athena—are said to aid his return.

7) Return home: reclaiming the household and confronting enemies

• Odysseus returns to Ithaca but cannot enter immediately because:
  • suitors/“men” occupy the palace and pressure Penelope to choose a new husband
  • their threat is implied as swallowing the kingdom
  • Telemachus is also at risk
• Odysseus uses strategy:
  • hides/disguises himself
  • gathers allies
  • later reveals identity
  • executes revenge by shooting arrows at the suitors
• Resolution:
  • Odysseus and Penelope reunite after 20 years.

8) Abrupt ending tension prevented by gods

• After the massacre, the suitors’ families prepare retaliation.
• Another fight seems imminent.
• Athena intervenes and halts the conflict:
  • Zeus intervenes (lightning), and both sides stop.

9) Final message about life, meaning, and mortality

• The lecture frames the Odyssey’s message as:
  • Odysseus rejects immortal godhood and chooses mortal life.
  • Even with hardship and twists, humans must find:
    • their own meaning and happiness within life
  • Death comes for everyone—so value must be found within life’s limits.

---

Speakers / sources featured

• Speaker: Kim Heon (scholar of Western classics; affiliated with the Institute for Humanities Research at Seoul National University)
• Cited author/figure: “Lemon Knot” (French novelist/poet; name unclear due to subtitle errors)
• Featured works (as discussed sources):
  • The Iliad (Ilias)
  • The Odyssey (Odis)
  • Cypria
  • Aethiopis
  • Little Iliad
  • The Fall of Ilion
  • The Return of Heroes
  • Telegoneia (mentioned)
• Mythological figures mentioned:
  • Achilles, Agamemnon, Chryses, Chryseis, Briseis, Apollo, Zeus, Athena
  • Thetis, Hector, Priam, Hecuba, Andromache, Helen
  • Odysseus, Phoenix, Ajax, Patroclus
  • Hephaestus, Poseidon
  • Calypso, Telemachus, Penelope
  • Alcinous, Nausicaa, Demodocus, Polyphemus
  • “Hyperion” (sun god referenced via oath/story element)
  • Additional subtitle-name/place variants appear unclear (e.g., “Talis,” “Talis’s arrow,” and other garbled place names).