《일리아스》 덕후 슐리만이 찾아낸 트로이 유적지

Scientific concepts / discoveries / nature-phenomena mentioned

Historicity of the Trojan War (maritime supremacy hypothesis)

• The war described in the Iliad is presented as historically uncertain.
• If it was real, scholars suggest it may have been about maritime supremacy and control of trade routes, not merely a political rivalry.
• A claimed timeline (based on Homer’s possible grounding in events) places a conflict roughly between 1300 and 1250 BCE.

Hittite diplomatic evidence linking to “Wilusa” (possible Troy)

• Discovery (1870): Many diplomatic documents were found in Hattusa, capital of the Hittite Empire.
• These texts record that in the mid-13th century BCE, a large force called Aiyava invaded Wilusa (a vassal state).
• The Hittites’ term Ahiyawa is said to correspond to the Mycenaeans/Achaeans.
• “Wilusa” is noted as sounding similar to Ilion (another name for Troy).
• Because the currently excavated “Troy” site is said to align with the location of Wilusa, the video claims it becomes “highly likely” that:
  • Mycenaeans invaded Wilusa, burned the city, and plundered it.

Bronze Age logistics as a driver (tin and trade routes)

• Bronze production constraints:
  • Copper is easier to source locally/regionally.
  • Tin ore is said to be abundant in Western Europe.
• Proposed economic mechanism:
  • Shipping tin to Anatolia/Mesopotamia could be highly profitable.
• Major route emphasized:
  • The Dardanelles Strait is described as difficult for Bronze Age ships due to strong currents, encouraging land transport inland.
• Troy’s location is argued to have benefited from tolls on that overland route.
• Conflict motive presented:
  • Mycenaeans (as traders) would regard Troy’s tolls as unfair and may have sought to seize control.
• Alternative hypothesis also mentioned:
  • The Trojan War could have been Mycenaean piracy rather than a grand trade-and-tolls dispute.

Archaeology at Hisarlik (stratigraphy and dating of layers)

• The video centers on stratigraphic excavation at Hisarlik Hill (identified with Troy).
• Core discovery framework:
  • Schliemann identified multiple ruin layers; later archaeologists debated which layer corresponds to Homeric Troy.

Schliemann’s excavations (1871–1873; expanded later with improved technique after 1878)

• 1871: Full-scale excavation begins after Ottoman permits.
• 1873: A 7-meter wall and traces of a Troy gate are found.
• Schliemann claims this is King Priam’s palace and searches for treasures.
• Treasure find:
  • Up to ~6,000 treasures, including metalwork, crowns, and copper shields.
  • A highlighted item: a gold hair ornament (Schliemann identifies it as Helen’s).
• Critiques:
  • Scholars argue some claims were unreliable (e.g., mocked as possible Constantinople purchases).
  • A major scientific critique: Schliemann reportedly excavated in ways that destroyed parts of stratigraphy, potentially mixing/obliterating evidence.

Layer chronology and interpretation (as described in the video)

• Schliemann’s total: nine layers reported after continued work.
• Video’s layer dating (approximate, as stated):
  • Layers 1–5: Early Bronze Age (~ 3000–1900 BCE); possibly related to precursors of Minoans/Mycenaeans.
  • Layers 6–7: Middle/Late Bronze Age (~ 1900–1000s BCE); then:
  • Layer 8: ~ 700 BCE, when Troy is described as burned and abandoned.
• The video specifically claims:
  • Schliemann’s “Troy of the Iliad” was in the second-to-last layer (described as Layer 6 in later discussion).
  • The layer interpreted as Homeric Troy should match Late Bronze Age ~1250 BCE to align with Trojan War narratives.
• Schliemann’s “ash pile” is interpreted as a trace of destruction by Mycenaeans.

Ongoing debate between Layer 6 and Layer 7

• Blegen/Dörpfeldt-type successor described:
  • The video names Bireln Dörvelfeldt (spelled as such).
  • He estimated Layer 6 corresponds to Homeric Troy.
  • Layer 6 is characterized as a fortress with strong walls and a defensive moat, destroyed by external invasion.
• Carl Blegen (named as Carl Black in the video) and others:
  • Excavations 1932–1938 concluded the Layer 6 city coincided with peak Mycenaean civilization and looked like it was destroyed.
  • They attributed destruction to an earthquake rather than an army (as stated).
  • They claimed part of Layer 7 (with blackened stones, broken arrowheads, and damaged skulls) is the Homeric Troy.
• Complication mentioned:
  • If Layer 7 (~1180 BCE) is war-destruction, the timing is said to coincide with the destruction of Mycenaean civilization by the Dorians/Sea Peoples, making a large invasion of Mycenaeans less plausible.
• Evidence gap:
  • A debated issue is the absence of a widely distributed Anatolian script in the Troy layers (and Schliemann supposedly damaged script evidence).
  • This lack makes proof linking Homeric Troy to a specific layer harder.

2018 discovery: “Tene” as a city tied to captive prisoners

• 2018: Traces of Tene, described as a forgotten Greek city used to house captives (prisoners taken during the Trojan War), were discovered.
• Source cited:
  • Pausanias (2nd century CE traveler/geographer) says Agaron allowed construction of a village for captives.
• Location/archaeology:
  • Tene is said to have been discovered during exploration of Peloponnese remains.
• Social-political claim:
  • The video says Tene prospered enough to have its own government.

Nature-phenomenon mentioned (as an alternative destruction mechanism)

• Earthquake destruction is explicitly mentioned as an alternative explanation for Layer 6 devastation (attributed to Carl Black/Blegen’s conclusions in the video).

---

List of researchers / sources featured

• Homer (referenced via Iliad; also indirectly via “Homer’s works” and naming Ilion/Troy)
• Scholars (general—no specific individuals)
• Harry Schliemann (amateur archaeologist; 19th century)
• Frank Calvert (shown as “Frank Kelbert” in subtitles; British diplomat and amateur archaeologist)
• Ottoman Empire (as authority for excavation permits; not a person)
• Bireln Dörvelfeldt (spelled as such; colleague continuing research after Schliemann—likely referring to W. Dorpfeld/Dörpfeld)
• Carl Black (subtitles spelling; likely Carl Blegen/Blegen; excavator 1932–1938 per video)
• Pausanias (2nd century CE geographer/traveler)