Why your art gets ignored online

Summary

Dr. Sean explains why finished artwork can receive little attention or unhelpful feedback online: a post that simply shows an image gives viewers no clear reason or direction to respond. Artists can encourage engagement and get more useful critique by stating what they want, narrowing the discussion, and giving viewers a specific way to join in.

Sharing art does not automatically invite critique. Artists and commenters should respect the poster’s purpose, ask permission before offering feedback, and make critique constructive. Artists should also consider who is giving advice and avoid letting harsh or unsolicited comments undermine their confidence.

Posting Strategies

• Post with a purpose: Decide whether you want praise, reactions, discussion, or critique.
• Pinpoint the feedback you want: Ask about a specific element, such as an expression, outfit, or background.
• Narrow the discussion: Explain what you’re working on or struggling with—for example, lighting, posing, or an expression—so responses stay relevant.
• Ask probing questions: For narrative art, invite viewers into the scene or story. For example, ask what a character might have done or what they would do in that situation.
• Use a call to action: Give people a direct prompt so they know how to respond and can imagine themselves engaging with the artwork.

Giving and Receiving Critique

• Ask permission before critiquing someone’s posted art. A post is not automatically an invitation for feedback.
• Respect the poster’s intent: Some people want to share their work or hear reactions; others are specifically seeking critique.
• Make feedback focused, direct, and actionable:
  • Focus on one or two areas.
  • Clearly identify the issue.
  • Suggest practical steps the artist can try rather than giving vague advice like “practice your foundations.”
• Be kind and professional.
• Evaluate the source of advice: The speaker recommends prioritizing feedback from artists who are somewhat more experienced or skilled in the area being discussed.
• Handle unsolicited or hostile comments selectively: Delete or ignore comments that are abusive, irrelevant, or seem intended to provoke a reaction.

The video features the speaker drawing while discussing story-driven artwork, characters, original characters, maps, and adoptables as examples of art that can benefit from more purposeful posts.

Creators and Contributors

• Dr. Sean, host of The Art Mentor
• Alex Hormozi, whose quote about people wanting others to succeed—but not more than themselves—is referenced.