Video summary
Why Think Tanks are a Billion Dollar Business
Main summary
Key takeaways
Think Tanks: The Business of Ideas
Think tanks are a large, diverse “business of ideas,” funded by wealthy individuals, corporations, and foundations. Their value can be difficult to quantify: some aim to shape policy directly, while others focus on convening people, developing leadership, and improving public dialogue.
Scale and Operating Models
- Scale: Caroline Elkins estimates that 8,000–10,000 nonprofit organizations worldwide work in this field, with 20% based in the United States. The five largest U.S. think tanks together reported roughly $1.3 billion in their latest fiscal years.
- Different models: Research-focused organizations such as Brookings and the American Enterprise Institute publish policy-relevant reports. The Aspen Institute describes itself as a “do tank”: rather than lobby or prescribe government policy, it convenes people to work through problems.
Aspen’s Strategy and Impact
When Dan Porterfield became CEO in 2018, he set two priorities: align the Institute’s programs into a sustainable, coherent organization and make it more relevant to younger generations. He cited a stronger organizational identity, more cross-program collaboration, and an increased ability to develop larger proposals for donations and impact as signs of progress.
Potential indicators of impact include whether an organization can bring trusted participants together, whether its ideas enter public debate, and whether partners and funders support its work. The Walton Family Foundation works with partners to define outcome measures, emphasizing that social-impact goals need to be clear even when results are difficult to quantify.
Funding can provide both resources and a signal of support. The Bezos Family Foundation contributed $186 million to create Aspen’s Center for Rising Generations, with the Walton Family Foundation and others also supporting the effort. The center consolidates Aspen’s youth work and invests in young people’s leadership.
Policy Influence
Think tanks may also measure impact through direct policy outcomes. The Heritage Foundation’s report became a major blueprint for the Reagan administration, which adopted two-thirds of its 2,000 recommendations. Heritage’s more recent Project 2025 is another example of an organization seeking direct policy influence.
Leadership and Resource Allocation
- Establish a clear purpose statement that defines what the organization does—and what it does not do.
- Align programs around that purpose so they reinforce one another.
- Treat money, time, and talent as capital, and make explicit choices about where to invest.
- Set clear outcome measures when pursuing systems change, while recognizing that not every meaningful result can be reduced to efficiency metrics.
Aspen worked with consulting firm SY Partners over six months to clarify its reason for existing.
The Sector’s Strategic Choice
The sector’s history reflects a shift from research intended to inform decision-makers toward more explicitly political organizations focused on achieving particular policy outcomes. The central strategic choice is whether to prioritize direct policy influence or broader goals such as dialogue, leadership, and human flourishing.
Presenters and Sources
Westin (interviewer/narrator); Caroline Elkins, Dan Porterfield, and Romy Drucker. Organizations discussed include the Aspen Institute, Brookings, the American Enterprise Institute, the Heritage Foundation, the Walton Family Foundation, and the Bezos Family Foundation.
Rate this summary
Your feedback will help improve summaries.
Improve this summary
Reprocess with a stronger model when the summary feels incomplete or inaccurate.
Translate summary in another language
Ask questions to this video
Chat for follow-up questions, clarifications, and source-backed answers.