Summary of "Którą wybierasz i dlaczego? BMW e39 i g30 xdrive"

BMW E39 (2003) vs. BMW G30 xDrive (2023)

Comparison of two generations of BMW 5 Series

Main Features & Highlights

BMW E39 (2003)

Classic design, widely appreciated and considered timeless.
Solid build quality with heavy, substantial materials (handles and interior parts feel very solid).
Longer wheelbase than predecessor E34, with a stiffer and more rigid body.
Engines ranged from a 150 hp inline-six (520i) to a V8 M5 version (first M5 with a V8 engine).
M5 E39 is collectible, limited production (~20,000 units), prices rising significantly.
Interior materials and assembly are high quality, with attention to detail and durability.
No corrosion or rust observed on tested example; well-maintained with 170,000 km mileage.
Driving experience described as “fabulous” and “superb,” with no feeling of age.
Prices for good six-cylinder models range roughly from 20,000 to 30,000 PLN; V8 models can reach 100,000 PLN+.
Diesel options (M57 engine) are praised for reliability and performance.
Overall, considered one of the best choices in its era and still highly regarded today.

BMW G30 xDrive (2023)

Modern design, visually the clear winner in looks compared to E39.
Interior materials feel lighter and more plastic-like, perceived as cheaper compared to E39’s solid feel.
Driver-focused cockpit with slightly tilted dashboard towards the driver.
Seats are good but not natural leather in the tested model; more premium options may be better.
Allows a lower seating position than E39, which some may prefer.
The tested model was a “naked” base variant, lacking extras.
Overall impression is solid and modern, but some criticism of material quality compared to E39.

Pros & Cons

E39 Pros

Timeless, classic design.
Exceptional build quality and materials.
Strong and varied engine lineup including collectible M5 V8.
Excellent driving experience with a solid, substantial feel.
Good condition examples are appreciating in value.
Diesel engines (M57) are reliable and well-regarded.

E39 Cons

Older technology compared to modern cars.
Maintenance and parts may be more challenging due to age.
Prices have risen, making good examples less affordable.

G30 xDrive Pros

Modern, attractive design.
Driver-oriented cockpit layout.
Advanced technology and newer features (not detailed in the video).
Lower seating position for some drivers.

G30 xDrive Cons

Interior materials feel cheaper and more plastic.
Base model lacks extras and premium touches.
Less tactile solidity in controls compared to E39.

User Experience & Impressions

The reviewer found the E39 surprisingly fresh and enjoyable to drive despite its age. The G30 felt more modern but lacked the tactile and material quality of the E39. E39’s driving position and build quality still impress even after 20 years. The G30’s styling is favored visually, but the interior quality is questioned. E39 is seen as a potential investment and collector’s car. The reviewer has personal experience with diesel variants and appreciates their reliability.

Comparisons & Additional Notes

E39 is compared favorably against the controversial E60 and E65 models, which are less liked due to weaker plastics and design choices.
The G30 is noted as a newer generation but with some compromises in interior quality.
The E39 M5 is noted as the first M5 with a V8 and highly collectible.
The price trajectory of E39 models is highlighted, with a significant increase over recent years.
The G30’s design origins are mentioned, referencing Japanese influence and Chris Bangle’s era, though not in detail.

Verdict / Overall Recommendation

The BMW E39 remains a highly respected and desirable classic 5 Series, offering exceptional build quality, a rewarding driving experience, and increasing collector value, especially in six-cylinder and V8 M5 variants. Despite its age, it does not feel outdated in terms of driving pleasure or material quality.

The BMW G30 xDrive, while visually more modern and driver-focused, falls short in interior material quality and tactile feel compared to the E39, especially in base trims. It is a solid modern car but lacks the timeless appeal and substance of the E39.

Recommendation: For enthusiasts and collectors, the E39 is the standout choice due to its classic qualities and investment potential. For those seeking modern styling and technology, the G30 is preferable but may feel less substantial inside.

Different Views / Speaker Contributions

One speaker emphasizes the tactile quality and solidity of the E39’s interior versus the lighter plastics of the G30.
Another highlights the driving experience and the timelessness of the E39.
There is a mention of personal ownership and experience with diesel engines in E39 and other BMW models.
Comments on pricing trends and collector interest come from the reviewer’s perspective.
The G30’s design and ergonomic improvements are noted but tempered by critiques of material quality.

Summary

The video compares the classic BMW E39 and the modern G30 xDrive, praising the E39 for its build quality, driving experience, and collector value, while acknowledging the G30’s modern design but critiquing its interior materials. The E39 is recommended for enthusiasts and collectors, while the G30 suits those wanting a contemporary BMW with updated features.