Poco X8 PRO vs Galaxy A57 vs Moto EDGE 70 - Qual melhor para você? Comparativo

Comparison Summary

The reviewer compares the Poco X8 Pro, Samsung Galaxy A57, and Motorola Edge 70, which typically cost around R$1,700–R$2,100 in Brazil, depending on discounts.

Each phone has a distinct strength: Poco for performance and battery life, Samsung for cameras and long-term software support, and Motorola for its slim design, wireless charging, and strong camera hardware.

Key Points by Category

Design and Durability

• The reviewer likes the look of all three phones, noting that design is largely a matter of taste. The Poco’s yellow color with black accents gets a positive mention.
• The Edge 70 is the thinnest and has a vegan-leather back, which the reviewer says is less prone to fingerprints, scratches, or breakage than the backs of the other phones.
• All three have USB-C, stereo speakers, side volume and power buttons, and a SIM tray.
• The Edge 70 has an extra shortcut button that opens Motorola’s AI features.
• The Poco and Edge 70 have IP68/IP69 ratings; the A57 has IP68, a first for the Galaxy A line. The reviewer considers all three well protected and says this should not be the deciding factor.

Charging and Convenience

• The Edge 70 is the only phone with wireless charging, which the reviewer finds especially handy when the phone is wet.
• The Poco includes a screen protector, case, and 100W charger in the box. The Edge 70 also includes its fast charger.
• The A57 supports 45W charging, but its charger is not included, adding an extra cost.

Displays

All three phones have 120Hz displays and in-screen fingerprint readers.

• Poco: 6.59-inch AMOLED, 1.5K resolution
• Edge 70: 6.67-inch P-OLED, 1.5K resolution
• A57: Full HD+ display

All three displays were judged excellent indoors. The reviewer thought the Samsung looked slightly brighter outdoors and ranked the displays Samsung first, Motorola second, Poco third, while stressing that the differences are small.

Performance

All three phones run smoothly for everyday use, but the Poco is far ahead for demanding games and long-term performance.

In a simultaneous Subway Surfers launch test, the Poco opened first, the A57 second, and the Edge 70 third. The tested Edge 70 had 12GB of RAM and still lost to the Poco.

The Poco’s Dimensity 8500 Ultra and LPDDR5 memory were described as dramatically more powerful—“almost twice” as powerful as the other two. The Edge 70 uses a Snapdragon 7 Gen 4, while the A57 uses an Exynos 1680. The reviewer places Samsung slightly ahead of Motorola in processing power.

The Poco scored about 2 million on AnTuTu. No exact scores were given for the other phones.

The reviewer recommends the Poco for gaming and demanding use. For people who do not game, the performance difference may not matter much.

Software Support

• Poco: 4 years of Android updates and 6 years of security updates
• Motorola: 3 years of updates, according to the reviewer
• Samsung: At least 6 years of updates, as stated in the video

Cameras

All three phones have a 50MP main rear camera and record rear-camera video in 4K.

• Edge 70: 50MP ultrawide and 50MP front camera
• Poco: 8MP ultrawide and 20MP front camera; the front camera does not record in 4K
• A57: 8MP ultrawide, an additional 5MP macro camera, and a 12MP front camera

Motorola and Samsung allow users to switch between cameras while recording; the reviewer says the Poco does not.

The reviewer’s overall comments favor the A57 for camera performance, while also praising the Edge 70, particularly its camera hardware. The Poco is considered good but weaker in this category. The video’s camera rankings are not entirely consistent: at one point, Motorola is described as ahead of Samsung, but the later overall recommendation favors Samsung for camera-focused buyers.

Battery

• Poco: 6,500mAh battery and 100W charging. The reviewer estimates a full charge takes about 50 minutes and says 20 minutes can provide roughly half a charge.
• Edge 70: 4,800mAh battery and 68W charging. The reviewer says the slim design comes with a battery-capacity trade-off.
• A57: 5,000mAh battery and 45W charging. The reviewer says it should comfortably last a day, but charging takes around an hour and a half, and the charger must be purchased separately.

With moderate or somewhat heavier use, the reviewer expects all three phones to last a full day. The Poco has the strongest battery and charging combination.

Verdict

• Choose the Poco X8 Pro for gaming, maximum performance, battery life, fast charging, and included accessories.
• Choose the Galaxy A57 if camera quality, display brightness, and longer software support matter most.
• Choose the Motorola Edge 70 for a thin, premium-feeling design, wireless charging, and strong camera hardware.

The reviewer’s overall advice is to choose based on your priorities—or buy whichever phone is cheapest at the time—since all three offer a solid everyday experience.

Speaker Perspective

Only one presenter contributes. He likes the design and general experience of all three phones, but gives the clearest performance and battery advantage to the Poco, the strongest overall camera recommendation to the Samsung, and special credit to Motorola for its slim design and wireless charging.