J'ai enquêté sur les meilleurs jeux d'enquête

Storyline / Framing

The video is less about a single game plot and more about defining and evaluating “investigative/deduction detective games.” The host uses Her Story as an emotional baseline: an investigative experience built around searching information, connecting clues, and feeling satisfaction when deductions click.

A major storyline thread also tracks the genre’s evolution over ~10 years (with references like Steam Detective Fest). The host additionally tries to distinguish between “detective games,” “deduction games,” “mystery games,” and what they prefer to call investigation games.

Gameplay Highlights (What Makes These Games “Investigative”)

Core Loop (Repeated Throughout the Genre)

• Explore / Gather Information
  • Read documents, examine environments, question characters, or open physical/computer “archives.”
• Find Clues
  • Each clue enables more searches, unlocks new branches, or constrains possibilities.
• Progress Toward Truth
  • Often through deduction: confirming/refuting hypotheses, eliminating incompatible options.
• Feel the “I Found It Myself” Satisfaction
  • Even if the game provides structure or guardrails, the player should feel ownership of the conclusion.

Two Main Ways Information Is Obtained (Spectrum)

• No searching for information (curated documents / direct materials)
  • Examples: Case of Road (as transcribed), Demon Maskerade.
• Player must search inside an environment/tool (heavy discovery)
  • Examples:
    • Her Story (search keywords in a police system)
    • Children of Clay (encyclopedia-style research)
    • Neurocracy (Omnipedia-like encyclopedia with little guidance)

Typical Investigation Mechanics

• Character/Object Exploration
  • Walking around, rummaging through rooms, drawers, paperwork, and evidence.
  • Example: The Case of the Golden Idol (unclear exact perspective, but furniture/pockets drive investigation).
• Interface-Driven Searching
  • Typing keywords, browsing pages, following links, reconstructing data.
  • Examples: the “computer search bar” idea from Her Story; encyclopedia research in Children of Clay.
• Physical Archive Traversal
  • Example: Los Wiki Cozlovka (as transcribed) / “a hand with many fingers.”
  • After identifying geography/date/initials, the player opens drawers, goes to the basement, retrieves boxes, and returns with documents—rewarding, sensory, and clearly mapped to progress.

Deduction Forms Discussed

• Elimination with Constraints
  • Similar to detective “timeline + alibi + opportunity” logic.
  • Often: suspects reduced until one fits.
• Logic-Grid / “Integral” Style Puzzles
  • Example referenced: Einstein’s riddle.
  • Best-method advice:
    • Build a structured table
    • Fill what you can immediately
    • Test scenarios and eliminate what conflicts with remaining clues
• Social-Rule / Narrative Sub-Doku Style
  • Family trees and conventional rules (marriage name changes, divorce effects, etc.).
  • Example: The Rotard Dead (as transcribed; likely referencing a detective genealogy-style puzzle)
  • Rules mentioned:
    • Children share parents’ last name
    • Wives may take husbands’ names
    • Divorce changes conventions
    • Restriction about same-gender marriage during the setting’s time period
• Constraint: “Same person can’t be in two places at once”
  • Used to solve murder/suspect setups (explicitly compared to whodunit logic).

Strategy / Key Tips Mentioned

• For logic-puzzle deduction (integral-style):
  • Make a table/grid
  • Start with cells you can fill directly
  • Use scenario testing (compare which hypothesis fits remaining clues)
  • Eliminate incompatible possibilities
• When a game offers “answer lists”:
  • The host criticizes “brute force” testing if the game validates too easily or too late, but praises systems that balance struggle and confirmation.
• For tuning “player experience” (developer-facing, but also advice for recognizing good investigations):
  • Use playtesting to tune:
    • how much information is shown
    • how it’s stored/displayed
    • what deductions are required
    • the logic-link pacing
• Validation systems praised:
  • Multi-step validation where the game checks only after the player likely has enough correct pieces.
  • This creates “doubt then confirmation” satisfaction.
  • Example: Lucas Pop’s Obradin (as transcribed).

Examples of Games Cited (And What the Host Says They’re Like)

Core Emotional Benchmark

• *Her Story*
  • Keyword search in an old police system
  • Clip-driven discovery
  • Satisfaction from logical deduction

Genre Distinctions / References

• Case of the Golden Idol
• Disco Elysium (repeated as a “boundary” many people bump into)
• Wolf Among Us (referenced as another point of confusion/genre overlap)
• Steam event highlight list includes (as cited): Aadin (transcribed), The Science of Black Manor (transcribed), Duck Detective (transcribed), D3 (transcribed), Disco Elysium, etc.

Investigation Mechanics Examples

• Hypnospace Outlaw (transcribed “Hypnos Space Outlow”): 90s website moderation; remove unauthorized content
• Children of Clay: identify a statuette using an encyclopedia
• The Operator: conspiracy unraveling (FBI/FBA agent per transcription)
• Mind Diver / “Mani Diver” / “Mind Diver” (transcription variations): digging through confused memories
• Neurocracy: encyclopedia search (Omnipedia-like) with heavy reading and low guidance
• SC Investigators (transcribed): first-person environment rummaging; criticized for tedious document hunting
• Euro Ro Trisarden (transcribed): reconstruct a family tree using a 90s search engine
• “Los Wiki Cozlovka” (transcribed): fictional CIA/arms-trafficking archive with drawer/basement box retrieval
• Type Help: austere text-only mystery/deduction game; recommended despite no audio/music
• Unhn (transcribed): dialogue/sound-based; acting reportedly immersion-breaking
• Outer Wilds: sometimes classified here, but described as more exploration/skill/narrative-adventure depending on the viewer
• Shadows of Doubt: praised for “freedom” and immersive-sim-inspired investigation (host didn’t get into it personally)
• Paradise Killer: atmosphere/universe-driven investigation; legal/political institutions and character empathy
• Demon Maskerade: one-week, six-person identification using demon powers and documentary evidence
• No Case Should Remain Unsolved: recommended
• Additional “epiphany puzzle” references (borderline/shared feeling): Tunic, One (Oo as transcribed), The Witness

Cases with Specific Deduction Styles

• Ace Attorney and Lucifer (transcribed): confronting testimony contradictions; get characters to revise stories
• BradIn (transcribed): identify victim/cause/culprit via role clues and elimination logic
• The Case of the Golden Idol: word-selection sentence completion using collected vocabulary snippets

End Credits: Gamers / Sources Featured

• Mark Brown (featured in the discussion via a referenced video)
• Sarah Beauieu (introduced/credited for the term “integ(r)am” style during a podcast episode reference)
• Lucas Pop (credited as the creator associated with Obradin in the host’s discussion)

(Other names appear as game titles rather than featured people—for example, Einstein is referenced as part of logic-riddle examples.)