Video summary

Evaluación Curricular - ¿Cómo se evalúa? Frida Díaz Barriga

Main summary

Key takeaways

Educational

Summary

The video presents curriculum evaluation as a systematic, ongoing process for judging whether a curriculum’s goals, resources, methods, and outcomes are appropriate. Evaluation should inform decisions about keeping, improving, or restructuring a curriculum—not simply measure final results. A sound evaluation uses both quantitative and qualitative information and considers the educational, institutional, and social context.

When and How to Evaluate

Curriculum evaluation may be undertaken when an institution plans to revise an existing curriculum or design one from scratch. Its form depends on the project’s stage, the institution and curriculum being assessed, the data required, the methods available, and the purpose of the evaluation.

Evaluation should be deliberate, systematic, and continuous. Reviewing only final outcomes can leave early design problems unnoticed. Evaluation should therefore consider the curriculum’s foundations and components, including social needs, employment conditions, student characteristics, objectives, teaching resources, and instructional plans.

Teachers, students, evaluators, and other relevant participants should be involved. Findings should be useful and relevant, as well as valid and reliable.

A General Sequence of Evaluation Steps

The video presents four operations, attributed to “Rafter,” as a guide rather than a fixed recipe:

  1. Define what will be evaluated.
  2. Specify the educational aspects and objectives to be assessed.
  3. Select or develop suitable instruments and procedures for those aspects.
  4. Review the information continuously, including the results of the earlier steps.

The process should be adapted to the particular curriculum and the stage being evaluated.

Four Broad Types of Evaluation

The video describes four types of evaluation that can be used during curriculum development:

  • Context evaluation: Diagnoses needs and problems and helps determine the project’s objectives. It is associated with the curriculum’s social and philosophical foundations.
  • Input evaluation: Helps plan the project and decide how to use available resources. It assesses whether the objectives, foundations, costs, benefits, and other conditions are feasible.
  • Process evaluation: Monitors implementation and provides ongoing feedback. It can identify or anticipate problems in a design or its application, support decisions, and maintain a record of how the project operates. Areas reviewed may include communication, relationships, logistics, student attitudes, and resources.
  • Product evaluation: Judges achievements, interprets overall results, and determines whether the project met its objectives and whether its outcomes are satisfactory.

Context and input evaluations are described as diagnostic; process evaluation is associated with formative, internal review; and product evaluation can have an external dimension.

Efficiency, Effectiveness, and Internal and External Evaluation

The video distinguishes two questions:

  • Efficiency: How well are resources—such as staff, time, and money—used?
  • Effectiveness: How closely do the results match the intended goals, and are the needs the program selected actually being met?

It then relates these questions to two perspectives:

  • Internal evaluation examines the curriculum’s organization and structure, including how its objectives, content, teaching activities, and resources fit together.
  • External evaluation considers results beyond the curriculum’s internal design, including graduates’ work, labor-market outcomes, and effects on social and community needs.

Internal Evaluation: Five Pedagogical Criteria

Glazman and de Ibarrola are cited for five criteria used to assess a curriculum internally:

  1. Congruence of the plan: Compare objectives at different levels and check them against the curriculum’s foundations. Look for omissions, errors, partial or mistaken assumptions, and contradictions.
  2. Feasibility: Compare objectives with available human and material resources. Inventory the resources and assess their accessibility, usefulness, cost, and actual utilization.
  3. Continuity: Examine how objectives and curricular components relate across the plan.
  4. Integration: Assess the relationships among objectives, subjects, and modules, and whether they form a coherent structure leading toward the program’s final objectives.
  5. Validity: Judge whether the curriculum remains relevant in light of its foundations and current conditions, and whether revision or improvement is needed at different levels.

The video also recommends attention to pedagogical principles such as content sequencing and dosage, feedback, and alignment between objectives and learning activities. Other considerations include quality, frequency, vocabulary, format, and the social criteria underlying the curriculum.

External Evaluation

External review focuses especially on what graduates do and whether the curriculum serves its intended purposes. Suggested areas include:

  • The professional functions graduates actually perform, compared with those the program was designed to prepare them for.
  • The labor-market sectors in which graduates work, including traditional, innovative, and potential fields.
  • Employment, unemployment, and overemployment patterns.
  • Graduates’ contributions to solving social and community problems the degree program was intended to address.
  • Resource use and costs, including average costs per semester, activity, student group, individual student, and overall program, considering both theoretical and practical activities.
  • Comparisons of costs, benefits, or results with those of other institutions.

In the video’s broad summary, internal efficiency is assessed through the curriculum’s congruence, feasibility, continuity, integration, and validity. External effectiveness is considered through graduates’ professional functions, labor-market participation, and contributions to community needs.

An Evaluation Model and Methods

The video describes the Educational Performance Evaluation Center model from Tucson, Arizona. It organizes evaluation around three dimensions:

  • Instruction: Content and knowledge in programs, instructional methods, teaching materials, learning principles, curricular organization, facilities, and costs.
  • Population: The curriculum’s effects on students, teachers, and administrative staff. Relevant information may include qualifications, experience, teaching skills, and professional activities.
  • Behavior: The knowledge, achievements, and skills students acquire, examined in relation to program objectives and Bloom’s three domains.

Possible data-collection approaches include formal and informal procedures, observations of programs and participants, analysis of student work, and the collection of judgments and opinions. The video also mentions systematic, evidence-based techniques associated with educational technology.

Data collection should be followed by analysis so the findings can guide decisions. Possible research designs include experimental, quasi-experimental, and ex post facto designs.

Díaz-Barriga’s Continuous Evaluation Proposal

The video presents a proposal based on stage four of Methodology of Curriculum Design for Higher Education: continuous curriculum evaluation. It has three sub-stages:

  1. Internal evaluation

    • Examine congruence among curricular objectives and assess their validity.
    • Assess whether the curriculum is viable given available human and material resources.
    • Review the sequence and relationships among components and whether they are suitable.
    • Check the appropriateness of content and activities in relation to epistemological and psychological principles and the student population.
    • Update subject matter and bibliography.
    • Examine academic, administrative, and institutional functioning.
    • Investigate teaching activity, its relationship to student performance, and factors associated with academic achievement.
  2. External evaluation

    • Continually investigate social needs.
    • Examine occupational-market conditions and relevant professional skills.
    • Investigate the scope of professional fields in the short and long term.
    • Compare the professional functions graduates perform with those anticipated by the program and those associated with programs at other institutions.
  3. Curriculum restructuring

    • Identify curricular elements that should be changed based on internal and external findings.
    • Develop a restructuring program and establish priorities.

Suggested methods include interviews, document analysis, applying educational technology, bibliographic research, demographic analysis of students and teachers, and expert judgment. The video does not specify particular expected outcomes for this methodology.

Speakers and Sources

  • Speakers: Two unnamed voices appear in a conversational presentation: one primarily explains the material, while the other asks questions and prompts clarification.
  • Main source: Frida Díaz-Barriga and collaborators, Metodología de Diseño Curricular para Educación Superior (1992).
  • Other sources or models cited: Glazman and de Ibarrola; “Rafter” (as rendered in the subtitles); Arredondo and Armas; the Educational Performance Evaluation Center model from Tucson, Arizona; and Bloom’s taxonomy.

Rate this summary

Your feedback will help improve summaries.

Improve this summary

Reprocess with a stronger model when the summary feels incomplete or inaccurate.

Pro

Translate summary in another language

Pro

Ask questions to this video

Chat for follow-up questions, clarifications, and source-backed answers.

Coming soon

Share this summary

Original video