03- شرح الحديث الثالث أركان الإسلام للشيخ محمد بن عثيمين

Main ideas and lessons

• Source and wording of the hadith

  • The hadith is narrated by Abu ʿAbdur-Raḥmān Abdullah ibn ʿUmar ibn al-Khaṭṭāb (may Allah be pleased with him).
  • He reports that he heard the Prophet ﷺ say:
    • “Islam is built upon five pillars.”

• Key linguistic/conceptual clarifications

  • “Abu ʿAbdur-Raḥmān” is a kunya (patronymic): a form of address beginning with a relationship such as father/mother/brother/uncle, etc.
  • The wording “may Allah be pleased with him” / “with them both” is a scholarly convention used depending on whether the companion and the relevant relative are both Muslims.

• Meaning of the “five pillars”

  • The pillars are:
    1. Testimony of faith: declaring that there is no god but Allah and Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah.
    2. Establishing prayer.
    3. Giving zakat.
    4. Performing Hajj (pilgrimage).
    5. Fasting Ramadan.

• Grammar/theological style note about the testimony

  • The discussion includes grammatical aspects of the testimony phrase, such as:
    • Different possible vowel/reading forms (dammah/kasrah).
    • The structure/substitution within the wording of the testimony.
  • Conceptually, the testimony part is framed as testifying to Allah’s oneness and Muhammad’s messengership.

• Order of Hajj and fasting

  • A concern is raised: the hadith’s ordering appears to place Hajj before fasting.
  • The resolution offered:
    • The order is a mnemonic (teaching/recall) order, not necessarily a strict chronological or priority order.
    • It contrasts with the hadith of Jibril, where fasting appears before Hajj.
    • Therefore, the difference in ordering is explained by mnemonic arrangement rather than different meanings.

• Underlying purpose: worship as a “test” of love and obedience

  • The five pillars are presented as tests for worship, especially by:
    • Giving up what is beloved
    • Abstaining from what is beloved
    • Exerting the body and/or wealth in obedience
  • Wealth is described as deeply loved by humans, so withholding it for zakat is a test.
  • Fasting is tied to a Hadith Qudsi concept: leaving food, drink, and desires for Allah’s sake.

---

Detailed methodology / instructional breakdown (how worship “tests” the person)

• Compare types of worship by what they require

  • Testimony of faith
    • Involves:
      • Utterance with the tongue
      • Belief in the heart
  • Prayer
    • Presented as purely physical worship (in this framing):
      • It includes bodily actions and recitation.
      • Matters like ablution are treated as prerequisites outside the “worship” itself.
  • Zakat
    • Treated as financial (not essentially physical) worship:
      • The essential obligation is transferring wealth to the poor.
      • Physical effort to deliver it (e.g., walking, renting a vehicle) is treated as outside the core worship act.
  • Fasting Ramadan
    • Presented as physical worship, but specifically abstinence:
      • The challenge is resisting what is otherwise easy to do.
  • Hajj
    • Discussed as financial and/or physical:
      • There is hesitation because costs and preparations (like water/food) might seem outside the core requirement—similar to how ablution is outside prayer itself.
      • However, if understood as involving both, it clearly becomes a “test” requiring:
        • giving up beloved things and
        • enduring hardship.

• Why multiple pillars matter

  • People differ: some find certain pillars easier and others harder.
    • For example, someone may be able to fast but struggle with zakat.
    • Another person may pray but struggle with fasting.
  • Having multiple pillars ensures the worshipper is tested across:
    • speech/belief
    • bodily acts
    • wealth expenditure
    • self-restraint

---

Example used to illustrate the “difficulty” logic behind expiation

• The speaker cites an example related to expiation (kaffārah) for sin:

  • Freeing a slave.
  • If that isn’t possible: fasting two consecutive months.
  • If that isn’t possible: feeding 60 poor people.

• Mufti explanation (preference by capability)

  • The ruling is framed as preference based on what is more difficult for the person:
    • Two months of fasting was more difficult for that king than freeing a slave.
  • Therefore, the order targets what is harder/easier for the person, aiming to address the sin properly and prevent recurrence.

• Key principle emphasized

  • Expiation’s purpose is to:
    • erase sin and
    • prevent it from returning.
  • “Preference” is not “envy”; it is discussed within broader jurisprudential principles (usūl al-fiqh).
  • The final takeaway: believers should follow what Allah obligates, and what remains is up to Allah.

---

Speakers / sources featured

• Speaker/teacher: Sheikh Muhammad ibn ʿUthaymīn
• Narrator of the hadith: Abu ʿAbdur-Raḥmān Abdullah ibn ʿUmar ibn al-Khaṭṭāb (may Allah be pleased with him)
• Prophet referenced: The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ
• Other referenced hadith source (comparison): The hadith of Jibril
• Referenced genre/source: Hadith Qudsi (about fasting meaning abstaining for Allah’s sake)