Video summary
I Got Hired At A Modeling Agency | Creep Cast
Main summary
Key takeaways
Overview
Creep Toast returns by reading fan stories from the Tales from the Creep subreddit. After a quick setup (including a content warning for the first tale), the hosts crack jokes while reacting to narratives that grow increasingly unsettling.
Story 1: “I Got Hired At A Modeling Agency and things got weird”
Frame & premise
A teacher, Alice, and her wife, Ren, are already stressed until a charming stranger, Howard Burton, recruits them for a “modeling company” focused specifically on legs and feet.
The pitch goes wrong immediately
Howard approaches them on the beach, compliments them, and asks creepy practical questions like shoe size. He also sells the deal with:
- Cash pay starting at $1,200/hour
- A 9 PM pickup time
- Strong “always-paid-in-cash” vibes
The website confirms the horror
Alice searches “True Niche,” which turns out to be a password-protected fetish site focused on niche body parts. The couple is told it’s not normal modeling—it involves buying and selling fetish content.
They go anyway (at first)
They’re taken to a studio and “placed” with other models. Their handler-photographer, Dave, instructs them to:
- Wear thongs and stilettos
- Pose on cue
- Follow rules that become increasingly restrictive
Escalation into extreme fetish content
The “gigs” intensify into progressively more violent and inhumane scenarios, including:
- Blood dipping
- “Premium” staged shoots
- Escalation into animal involvement (tarantulas, snakes, cockroaches)
- Needles and eventually “exclusive” content involving torturing/crushing
A character named Crystal becomes a “new friend” and hints it will get worse. When Alice finally refuses and tries to leave, Howard offers “exclusive” pay boosts with a chilling smile.
Alice quits—then gets pulled back in
After quitting, Alice later discovers a password tied to Howard’s business card and finds the “exclusive” gore/fetish catalog, including titles like:
- Frog Stomp
- Roach Crush
- Kitten Squish
Final twist (at the worst time)
Ren ends up in a hit-and-run hospital situation, and Alice realizes she has been forced back into the operation due to desperation.
Revenge-horror ending
Alice is led to a tied-up man and forced to pay to “earn” money through a horrific stomp execution (cash exchange, “same time tomorrow”).
Host feedback highlights
- The comments debate whether the story is splatterpunk-adjacent.
- The hosts praise the concept of a teacher sliding into a disgusting secret world.
- They note the violence could be more effectively “catalyzed” for pacing—such as stronger early triggers (e.g., imminent job loss).
Story 2: “The smell in the boy’s restroom is getting worse” (Flush Fries)
Complaint-to-calamity horror
A janitor team—Percy and Lenny—enters the boys’ bathroom. The smell isn’t just bad; it smells “alive”, and it becomes unbearable within minutes.
Mundane explanations fail
Attempts to solve it go nowhere:
- Air fresheners
- Out-of-order signs
- Gas inspectors Even when nothing toxic is found, the smell persists—and begins to spread.
Quirky turn before dread peaks
The narrator briefly recalls a terrible eighth-grade memory (kids doing gross, violent things). Then the story snaps back into escalating horror beats.
Percy’s horrifying end
The smell intensifies. The school loses power repeatedly, and earthquakes begin. Percy is later found in his trailer with:
- His cat dead
- Air fresheners everywhere
- Percy maimed from the inside, digging at his face/nose with bleeding and corruption
The sinkhole reveal
Earthquakes expose a massive cavern beneath the school. The narrator and Coach Tomkins rig a camera on a long wire to explore the drain space and eventually see a troglodyte-like mass of decayed, insect/rot-adjacent beings reaching toward the light—pleading, crying—then pulling away.
The sinkhole collapses the restroom area, and Coach Tomkins dies.
Final tone
In the emergency room, a nurse jokes about being “poor old Lazarus,” then casually notes the town has lingering evil smells, implying supernatural persistence beneath the surface.
Story 3: “Golden House” (cosmic / Lovecraftian)
Ritual viewpoint
Years after a childhood where the community collects golden items (including jewelry/earrings) to build a golden shrine/mask/halo, a girl is carried into a church-like procession.
The offering
She’s lowered into the “golden house” through a chimney-like opening as part of a ritual tied to a “God.”
Cosmic body horror and transformation
Inside darkness:
- Flies become firefly-like entities
- Alien, gold-infused “moss”/insects appear
- They burrow, bind, and replace her body functions
The true entity
She encounters the “God”: a degraded, insect-ridged, gold-masked figure with multiple arms. It communicates through sensation rather than speech.
Possession becomes divinity
The girl absorbs the godlike role, gaining the ability to:
- See through countless eyes
- Share the entity’s hunger
Ending punchline
She becomes the vessel/mother figure—suggesting the “Golden House” requires ongoing transfers of host/faith, with her father ultimately worshiping her as the new “God.”
Standout jokes / host reactions (recap)
- They frequently mock the first story’s fetish realism, including:
- “Exclusive” = “another word for porn”
- Olive Garden-style jokes
- The absurdity of “what size shoe?”
- During the teacher-to-fetish pivot, they debate whether it leans into splatterpunk or splatterpunk-adjacent territory.
- For the bathroom smell story, they enjoy comedic beats between disgust and horror, including hamster/animal classroom-style memories and timing gags—while still praising the Junji Ito-like vibe.
Main themes across the three stories
- Hidden horrors behind normal life: teachers, schools, and religion masking something predatory underneath.
- Body transformation / possession: fetish exploitation, internal rot/disease horror, and insect-god assimilation.
- Secrecy enforced by circumstance: money, social pressure, fear, and ritual mechanics keeping characters trapped.
Personalities appearing
- Hunter
- Isaia
- Ren (Story 1)
- Alice (Story 1)