Summary of "Commodore's NEW Computer - Commodore 64 Ultimate Review"

Commodore 64 Ultimate Review

The Commodore 64 Ultimate is a modern FPGA-based recreation of the original Commodore 64 computer, combining faithful hardware emulation with contemporary features and conveniences.

Main Features

FPGA Recreation: Faithful hardware recreation of the original Commodore 64 motherboard using FPGA technology.
Memory & Performance: Equipped with 128 MB RAM and a Turbo Boost mode for overclocking.
Compatibility: Supports legacy peripherals such as original tape drives, disk drives, and joystick ports.
Video Output: Provides both modern HDMI output (up to 1280x1024 resolution) and legacy video output simultaneously, allowing connection to CRTs and modern displays at the same time.
Software Loading: Games and software can be loaded from SD cards or USB sticks.
SID Sound: Dual SID chip sockets for authentic sound using original SID chips; FPGA emulation supports up to 8 SID chips simultaneously.
Manual Included: Comes with a spiral-bound user manual teaching programming and hardware usage, echoing the original C64 manuals.
Multiple Editions: Three SKUs available:
- Basic Beige ($350): Classic look with the best keyboard build quality.
- Starlite Edition ($400): Clear case with LED lighting, but keyboard flex issues.
- Founders Edition ($550): Gold keycaps and clear gold case.
Open Platform: Motherboard can be swapped into an original Commodore 64 case.
Overclocking / Super CPU Mode: Allows boosting clock speeds significantly, improving performance on some games, though with some graphical artifacts and gameplay speed issues.
Legacy Support: Supports original peripherals and software, including tape and disk drives.
High Compatibility: Claims 99% compatibility with the vast C64 software library (~10,000 titles).
Homebrew & Demos: Supports active homebrew games and classic scene demos, including new titles like Sherwood, Super Mario Brothers port, Eye of the Beholder remake, and others.
Accessories Included: HDMI cable, power supply, stickers, and a USB stick styled as a cassette with software.

Pros

Extremely faithful hardware recreation with modern enhancements.
Fast boot times comparable to the original C64.
Excellent video output flexibility (HDMI + legacy CRT simultaneously).
High software compatibility and support for original peripherals.
Inclusion of original-style manual is a rare and appreciated touch.
Open design allows motherboard swaps into original cases.
Overclocking capabilities breathe new life into older games.
Supports authentic SID chips for purists.
Multiple aesthetic options to suit different tastes.
Competitive pricing considering the technology and included features.
Great for both nostalgia and new Commodore 64 enthusiasts.

Cons

Keyboard quality varies by edition:
- Starlite edition suffers from noticeable keyboard flex and an unsatisfactory space bar feel.
- Basic Beige model has better keyboard quality.
Shift lock key is non-mechanical (software-controlled).
Some manufacturing issues like fragile cassette USB case and glued-in power supply packaging.
Overclocking can cause visual artifacts and gameplay speed issues unless games are patched.
Possible legal issues with Commodore branding in the EU may cause delays or rebranding.
Internal speaker for drive sounds considered gimmicky by reviewer.
NTSC/PAL mode issues when using legacy video output with CRTs, potentially causing rolling or black-and-white images.
Super CPU patches are currently limited in availability.

User Experience

The reviewer spent several weeks with the device and found it easy to use:

Setup and configuration through a multifunction rocker switch and menu is intuitive.
Video quality on HDMI is excellent with customizable resolution and scanline options.
Loading games from SD/USB is straightforward.
Playing both classic and new homebrew titles is enjoyable, with some games running better than on original hardware.
The ability to use original peripherals adds authenticity and nostalgia.
Keyboard issues are edition-dependent; the beige model is recommended for a better typing feel.
Overall build quality is solid aside from some minor packaging and keyboard flex issues.

Comparisons

Overclocked games run smoother than on other retro recreations like the Omega 500 Mini.
Keyboard and build quality of the Starlite edition is inferior to the original C64 and the beige edition.
The FPGA implementation is praised as superior to many other C64 clones or emulators.
The product consolidates existing aftermarket FPGA motherboards, cases, and keycaps into one official product.

Additional Notes

The Commodore 64 Ultimate revives the Commodore brand after multiple ownership changes and bankruptcy.
The reviewer was initially skeptical due to the brand’s troubled history but was ultimately impressed.
Positioned as the first official Commodore 64 hardware in over 30 years.
Price is justified given modern tech costs and the convenience of an all-in-one package.

Speakers’ Additional Views

Reviewer’s personal history with the original C64 adds credibility and nostalgia.
Emphasis on the educational value of the included manual.
Enthusiasm for the active homebrew and demo scene on the C64 platform.
Interest in future development of Super CPU patches to improve game compatibility.
Practical advice on legal issues and regional compatibility considerations.

Verdict / Overall Recommendation

The Commodore 64 Ultimate is an excellent, faithful, and modern FPGA-based recreation of the classic Commodore 64, offering:

High compatibility
Modern conveniences
Authentic features like SID chip support

While there are minor build quality issues (notably keyboard flex on some editions) and potential legal hurdles in Europe, these do not detract significantly from the overall quality. The inclusion of an original-style manual, support for legacy peripherals, and the ability to overclock games make it a compelling choice for both nostalgic fans and new users.

Priced competitively for 2026, the reviewer highly recommends the Commodore 64 Ultimate as the best way to experience the C64 today, effectively replacing the need to use original hardware.

Summary

The Commodore 64 Ultimate is a well-engineered, feature-rich, and authentic modern recreation of the classic C64, with excellent compatibility and modern outputs, making it a top choice for retro computing enthusiasts despite minor build issues and regional legal uncertainties.