Video summary

Accents -- Where and Why?: Kathryn Campbell-Kibler at TEDxOhioStateUniversity

Main summary

Key takeaways

Educational

Summary

Linguist Kathryn Campbell-Kibler argues that an accent is not simply a measurable feature that some people have and others lack. Ideas about who “has an accent,” and which speech counts as correct or standard, are shaped by social history and people’s judgments.

Main Ideas

  • People have mixed attitudes toward accents. An accent can signal belonging and authenticity, such as being recognizably from New York, Boston, or the South. At the same time, people often describe speech considered accentless as “educated,” “clear,” or easy to understand.
  • The sense that one’s own speech is correct is called “linguistic security.” Campbell-Kibler says many Ohioans feel that their speech is simply normal. One Dayton resident even described people in Columbus and Dayton as speaking “like God.”
  • A standard language is a social convention, not a purely linguistic fact. What people call “correct English” reflects a language’s social and political history rather than an objectively superior way of speaking.
  • Standards have emerged in different ways.
    • In England and France, the speech associated with political power—London and Paris—became the model for the standard.
    • In Iceland, rural speech was chosen partly because urban speech was associated with Danish influence and viewed as less “pure.”
    • In the United States, regional standards existed before a nationwide standard took hold. People who wanted to sound educated often imitated wealthy and influential people in their own region.
  • Radio helped establish a national American standard. When nationwide broadcasts became possible in the first half of the twentieth century, broadcasters had to decide what a trusted, educated national voice should sound like. Rather than choosing New York or Washington, D.C., they promoted a Midwestern model. Campbell-Kibler says this choice was influenced by the era’s anti-immigrant attitudes and an idealized image of the Midwest. Ohioans consequently came to be associated with “good” or standard speech—not because their speech was inherently better, but because of that history.
  • Ohio itself does not speak uniformly. Campbell-Kibler describes a dialect boundary running through the state. Central Ohio and Northern Ohio are undergoing different vowel changes, which she illustrates with young women saying the word class differently.
  • People disagree about where Ohio’s speech differences lie.
    • In maps drawn by Central Ohioans and some Southern Ohioans, Central Ohio appears as an unmarked, “normal” center. Around two-thirds of those respondents recognized Northern Ohio as speaking differently, while about one-third did not. Respondents generally recognized Southern Ohio as distinct.
    • Northern Ohioans were more divided: roughly a third said they spoke like Columbus residents, a third acknowledged that their own speech sounded different, and a third—whom Campbell-Kibler calls “resisters”—said that Columbus residents were the ones with an accent.
    • In her analysis, the “resisters” showed more of the northern vowel pattern than other Northern Ohioans, even as they rejected the idea that their own speech was unusual.
  • Whether Cleveland “has an accent” remains unsettled. Campbell-Kibler’s point is that the answer depends not only on how people speak, but also on whether the community comes to recognize and label those differences.

Takeaway

People’s judgments about accents help create social meanings; they do not merely describe speech. Treating one way of speaking as normal and another as inferior can pressure people to choose between sounding like their community and sounding “educated.” Campbell-Kibler questions whether that is a choice people should have to make and celebrates the variety of ways people speak.

Speakers and Sources Featured

  • Kathryn Campbell-Kibler — main speaker.
  • Unnamed Dayton interviewee — quoted describing Columbus and Dayton speech as “like God talks.”
  • Theodore Roosevelt — archival speech clip used to illustrate a regional pronunciation.
  • William Howard Taft — archival speech clip used as a contrasting example.
  • Unnamed young woman from Central Ohio — recorded example of saying class.
  • Unnamed young woman from the Cleveland area — recorded contrasting example of saying class.
  • Unnamed Northern Ohio woman — quoted describing how her speech sounds after a couple of glasses of wine.
  • Unnamed Cleveland resident quoted in a Twitter study — says she is tired of being told she has an accent and that Columbus residents have one.
  • Walter Cronkite — cited as an example of a newscaster whom Ohioans associate with standard speech; not presented as a speaking clip in the subtitles.
  • Research sources mentioned: the Atlas of North American English; Campbell-Kibler’s maps of Ohioans’ perceptions; and a study examining how people discuss accents on Twitter.

Rate this summary

Your feedback will help improve summaries.

Improve this summary

Reprocess with a stronger model when the summary feels incomplete or inaccurate.

Pro

Translate summary in another language

Pro

Ask questions to this video

Chat for follow-up questions, clarifications, and source-backed answers.

Coming soon

Share this summary

Original video