Jack Frost (1997) Vs. Jack Frost (1998)

Comparison

Matt compares the two films titled Jack Frost and strongly prefers the 1997 low-budget killer-snowman horror comedy over the 1998 Michael Keaton family comedy.

The 1997 Horror Comedy

Matt finds the horror film’s rough practical effects—including the snowman’s conspicuously mitten-like hand—more charming than the other film’s dated CGI and puppetry. He also enjoys its goofy, knowingly cheesy one-liners and inventive kills. The snowman impales victims with icicles, uses a sled to decapitate someone, and turns Christmas ornaments into “teeth.”

Matt also recalls a bizarre scene involving Shannon Elizabeth and a carrot that abruptly disappears, joking about where it went.

The 1998 Family Comedy

By comparison, Matt finds the Keaton movie forgettable, with comedy that often feels awkward. He says Keaton seems bored and feels the story does little with its snowman premise beyond a few scattered set pieces. He gives the puppetry some credit but considers the effects and humor less successful overall.

Verdict

Matt’s verdict is emphatic: the 1997 horror film is faster, more inventive, and more fun to rewatch. He briefly mentions its sequel, which he liked much less, but still considers the original the clear winner.

People Mentioned

• Matt (reviewer)
• Michael Keaton
• Shannon Elizabeth
• Henry Rollins
• Dzel Zappa