Video summary
Don't Use STAR in Your Next Interview (Do This Instead)!
Main summary
Key takeaways
Summary
Jeff Su compares two frameworks for answering behavioral interview questions:
- STAR: Situation, Task, Action, Result.
- CARL: Context, Action, Result, Learning.
Su argues that STAR can lead candidates to spend too much time on background and stop at the result, leaving out what they learned. This can make answers feel formulaic or memorized. CARL combines STAR’s Situation and Task into a shorter Context, creating more room for accomplishments and reflection.
CARL playbook
- Context: Briefly explain what you were trying to accomplish and why.
- Action: Describe specifically what you did.
- Result: State the outcome.
- Learning: Explain what the experience taught you and how it will shape your future actions.
To develop the Learning portion, ask yourself:
- What do my actions and results imply?
- What did I do well?
- What would I do differently in a similar situation?
Examples
- Going above and beyond at EY: Su used downtime between consulting projects to design a training program for new hires. The CARL version gets to the context more quickly than the STAR version, leaving more time to explain his actions and takeaways.
- A failed fitness-content effort: After a well-received presentation on fitness and nutrition, Su posted home-workout videos for a wider audience. Fewer than 1% of his connections liked or viewed the posts. He concluded that the content could not compete with established fitness coaches, but used the video-editing skills he had gained to pursue a topic better suited to his expertise: career and interview advice.
Practical recommendations
- Use CARL in behavioral interviews when you want to demonstrate reflection, adaptability, and how you would apply lessons in the future.
- Keep the context concise and prioritize actions, results, and learning.
- Don’t literally say “Context,” “Action,” “Result,” or “Learning” during the interview; use the framework to organize your answer.
- Use STAR for resume bullets, where concise, results-oriented outcomes—ideally supported by data—matter more than lessons learned. If STAR already works well for your interview answers, Su says there is no need to abandon it.
Metrics and source
The only quantified outcome mentioned is that fewer than 1% of Su’s connections engaged with or viewed the fitness posts. No business targets, revenue figures, or timelines are provided.
Presenter: Jeff Su
Rate this summary
Your feedback will help improve summaries.
Improve this summary
Reprocess with a stronger model when the summary feels incomplete or inaccurate.
Translate summary in another language
Ask questions to this video
Chat for follow-up questions, clarifications, and source-backed answers.