Video summary
We Tested Every Steak Myth
Main summary
Key takeaways
Steak Myths and Test Results
Key Findings
- Resting: Carryover cooking varies with steak thickness, fat content, pan heat, oil, and flipping frequency. In one test, a steak pulled at 52°C climbed to about 65°C; another, pulled at 42°C, peaked around 52.5°C. These results apply to the specific steaks and cooking setups tested, not to every steak.
- Practical approach: Instead of automatically pulling a steak a set number of degrees below your target, monitor its temperature. If it is already close to your preferred doneness, slice it when it reaches that temperature to stop it cooking further. Resting is still an option when there is room for carryover cooking.
- Flipping: Frequent flipping cooked the steak faster and more evenly, with better contact for browning. In the test, the frequently flipped steak also carried over about 2°C more. Flip as you’re able; there’s no need to use a stopwatch.
- Tempering: A steak brought to a 25°C surface temperature over several hours and a fridge-cold steak at about 5°C had broadly similar gray bands after cooking. The warmer steak spent less time in the pan and developed a weaker crust. The test suggests tempering made less difference to the interior gradient than expected.
- Searing: Listen for sizzling as a cue that the surface is hot enough to sear. A probe can help track temperature. For a strip steak, insert it through the center, parallel to the direction you plan to slice.
Methods Shown
Chris’s Perfect Steak
Ingredients
- Zabuton steak, a tender muscle from the chuck shoulder
- Beef tallow and herbs for the sous-vide bag
- Beef tallow and duck fat for frying
- Pepper and thyme or other herbs
- Bordelaise sauce; Chris used extra beef tallow because he had no bone marrow
Method
- Sous-vide the steak at 130°F / 54°C. Chris estimated it reached about 128°F, resulting in a doneness slightly on the rare side of medium-rare.
- Blot excess surface moisture.
- Briefly deep-fry in beef tallow and duck fat to brown the exterior. Since the steak is already at its target doneness from sous-vide, it does not need to rest after this short finishing fry.
- Blot off excess oil, slice, and serve with pepper, herbs, and bordelaise sauce.
Andy’s Perfect Steak
Ingredients
- A thick steak with medium-to-high marbling, around a 6–7 marbling score; Andy likes crossbred Wagyu or Black Angus
- Salt
- Beef tallow
- Charcoal and a little wood for grilling
Method
- Lightly trim the steak to allow for a thicker cut.
- Salt all sides and leave uncovered on a rack in the refrigerator overnight to dry-brine.
- Set up a two-zone charcoal grill, with one hot side and one cooler side for managing flare-ups. Add some wood for smoke.
- Use beef tallow, place the steak on the grill, and weight it with a press for good contact.
- Flip frequently to build char and cook more evenly.
- Pull the steak at about 42°C, then let carryover cooking bring it to around 52°C before slicing.
- Serve with triple-cooked fries.
Equipment and Prep
- Probe thermometer; insert it through the steak’s center, parallel to the planned slicing direction
- Pan and induction burners for the comparison tests
- Deep fryer and sous-vide setup for Chris’s steak
- Charcoal grill with two heat zones, a steak press, and a rack for overnight dry-brining
The test steaks were dry-brined, so no extra salt was added during the pan-cooking demonstrations.
Presenter/channel: Andy Cooks, with guest Chris Young.
Referenced sources: Chris Young’s video Resting Steak Is a Myth; a prior physics discussion about frequent flipping, attributed in the subtitles to “Harold.” Chris’s triple-cooked chips are featured in a follow-up video.
Rate this summary
Your feedback will help improve summaries.
Improve this summary
Reprocess with a stronger model when the summary feels incomplete or inaccurate.
Translate summary in another language
Ask questions to this video
Chat for follow-up questions, clarifications, and source-backed answers.