Video summary

WILDBERRIES НЕ ВЫЖИВЕТ/ ДЕФИЦИТ БЕНЗИНА/ РЕКОРДНЫЙ ДЕФИЦИТ БЕНЗИНА/ ПРОБЛЕМЫ РЕТЕЙЛЕРОВ. Милов

Main summary

Key takeaways

News and Commentary

Summary of Key Arguments and Reported Developments

1) Gasoline crisis returns; queues and refinery damage linked to strikes

  • The presenter argues that the prior temporary stabilization (when attacks briefly eased) has worn off.
  • Ukrainian strikes are said to have resumed on Russian refining capacity, causing refinery shutdowns and reduced output.
  • Gas station queues are reported to be back, with the impact spreading from regional areas into Moscow and large cities.
  • He criticizes the official narrative:
    • Rosstat is cited as reporting “slight deflation” and falling fuel prices.
    • The presenter counters that independent stations still price fuel below 100 rubles, but fuel shortages persist.
  • Analyst/press expectation: August gasoline/refining output will likely decline again, with impacts worsening into autumn and weighing on the wider Russian economy.

2) Price-control “agreements” won’t solve shortages; they create accumulated losses

  • In regions such as Novosibirsk, local authorities are described as trying to manage the crisis via price controls agreed with gas station chains.
  • The presenter argues this approach fails repeatedly because:
    • businesses must cover objective costs and remain profitable,
    • artificial price suppression leads to non-payments and debt,
    • which later triggers sharper price jumps.

3) Retail pressure mirrors fuel problems: big retailers report near-zero profits

  • The presenter claims similar dysfunction is emerging in retail markets.
  • He references newly released reports from major chains (notably X5 Retail Group and Lenta), saying:
    • profits have dropped sharply to near zero,
    • with net profitability for X5 below ~2%.
  • Causes offered include:
    • reduced purchasing power among the population (unable to pay profitable prices),
    • administrative price pressure, described as analogous to gasoline “containment.”
  • Conclusion: retail is portrayed as structurally unprofitable at present, with companies “spinning” to maintain market presence.

4) Wildberries fallout is framed as macroeconomic-level damage

  • The presenter discusses a Forbes report and a State Duma roundtable involving Wildberries and sellers.
  • He claims damage is escalating weekly, including:
    • Direct damage to Wildberries warehouses: roughly 200–300 billion rubles
      • earlier cited figure: 60–80 billion rubles direct warehouse damage, excluding seller losses
    • Restoration of warehouse infrastructure: 150–220 billion rubles
      • plus additional costs (waste removal, land reclamation, dismantling), potentially bringing totals to ~300 billion rubles
    • Seller losses: 600–700 billion rubles (possibly more) affecting 400,000+ sellers (nearly half a million)
  • He emphasizes combined losses could reach “a trillion rubles or more,” calling it macroeconomically significant, with effects such as:
    • stress on banking receivables and overall debt,
    • increased pressure on the state budget deficit.
  • He also argues the crisis extends beyond sellers:
    • Wildberries’ own business model is described as broken, because it had banked on reaching profitability later via financial synergy (including with VTB), but is now facing losses without expected profits to offset them.
  • He frames the situation as possibly challenging the broader viability of a “platform economy” under conditions where large warehouses may become persistent targets, and where marketplace and financial profitability are interconnected.

5) The “economic attack perimeter” may expand beyond warehouses and oil

  • After Wildberries warehouses, the presenter says attacks are increasingly reaching other concentrated nodes:
    • export terminals, especially grain terminals, disrupting exports and worsening forecasts.
  • Mechanism described:
    • export interruptions lead to domestic oversupply,
    • wholesale wheat prices fall,
    • farmers face losses and reduced incomes.
  • He predicts escalation risks to additional sectors, including:
    • military-industrial production (likely harmful though consequences are unclear),
    • other Russian manufacturing tied to critical industries or cash flows (where destruction of a single component could halt production).

6) Budget deficit hits record levels; overspending and recession risk

  • The presenter calls the July budget deficit “hellish,” breaking records.
  • He says it is now close to ~double the planned annual level.
  • He argues worsening will accelerate in the fall because:
    • the government cannot control expenditures,
    • spending above plan is used to prevent GDP from collapsing.
  • He notes that even a better oil-price environment has not prevented deterioration, suggesting oil revenue may not solve structural fiscal problems.
  • He characterizes the system as a “financial pyramid”, arguing that military and substitution/import-related spending requires continually increasing state financing.

7) Liquidity shortage and tighter enforcement: tax evasion cases rise

  • The presenter states Russia faces an ongoing liquidity/credit crunch.
  • He cites claims that businesses have gone “underground” and reduced tax payments due to heavier tax burdens.
  • Media/official reporting is referenced to support a rise in tax-crime cases, described as up nearly 20% in the first half of the year.
  • He argues enforcement can worsen liquidity:
    • if businesses are pursued and forced into cash constraints, tax receipts and solvency pressures increase rather than ease.

8) Inflation narrative questioned; market distrust of Rosstat; ruble weakness noted

  • The presenter dismisses Rosstat’s micro-deflation narrative as uncredible.
  • He says market reaction has been negative and that prices for items (e.g., cucumbers and sugar) are rising again.
  • He points to rejected fuel-price “drops” as evidence supporting claims that Rosstat is manipulating or misrepresenting data.
  • He also notes ruble weakness:
    • Central Bank rate reportedly above 84 rubles per dollar,
    • Forex around ~86,
    • suggesting discussion about a move toward 100 rubles per dollar.

9) Europe LNG purchases: claims of crisis are challenged

  • The presenter addresses headlines that the EU is increasing LNG purchases from Russia due to shortages.
  • He argues the spike occurred mainly in the first quarter, driven by panic from supply disruptions around “Armuz.”
  • After that, he claims EU LNG purchases declined.
  • He reports that storage in mid-August is about 60% full, not catastrophic, and that Europe may reach ~80%+ by winter.
  • He reiterates:
    • Europe’s obligation to phase out LNG imports by January 1,
    • Russia’s logistical/transport constraints in rerouting LNG to Asia.

Presenters or Contributors

  • Vladimir Milov (main presenter)

Original video