Het grootste vleesbedrijf ter wereld zit achter deze vleesvervangermerken | LUBACH

Overview

The episode argues that Brazil’s JBS—the world’s largest meat processor—has quietly entrenched itself in the Netherlands and even owns prominent Dutch “meat substitute” brands. The segment suggests this undermines the idea that plant-based products are a genuine break from factory farming.

Key Points and Allegations Highlighted

• JBS presence in the Netherlands

  • The episode claims JBS moved its headquarters to the Netherlands about two years ago, with shareholder meetings held there.
  • Greenpeace is said to have protested during a shareholder meeting at a building near Schiphol.

• Scale of the business

  • JBS is presented as operating across five continents with extremely large slaughter and daily meat output—framed to emphasize its global dominance.

• “Arjen’s Shitty Companies” rating

  • The host uses a satirical “quality mark” with 10 categories (including corruption, deforestation, climate impact, unsafe/dangerous practices, child labor, etc.).
  • JBS is depicted as receiving the maximum: five stars, with multiple issues cited:
    • Corruption and bribery in Brazil
      • Allegations include large-scale political bribery (“assembly-line bribery”) and a political crisis following leaked recordings (“Joesley Day”).
    • Insider trading and imprisonment
      • The Batista brothers are said to have gone to jail, also tied to insider trading.
    • Deforestation
      • Meat processing is linked to major forest loss (reported as 1.7 million hectares over 11 years).
    • Climate damage
      • The show claims JBS’s emissions across the supply chain exceed those of Italy.
    • Spoiled meat / dangerous food practices
      • Reports allege spoiled meat was repackaged and shipped, inspectors were allegedly bribed, and chemicals were used to mask bad odors.
    • Political relationships
      • The episode claims JBS has ties to major political figures, including large donors to Trump’s inauguration.
    • Tax evasion, poor working conditions, and exploitation
      • Allegations include labor exploitation and unsafe conditions, including children hired via a cleaning contractor to handle hazardous slaughterhouse waste.

• Ownership of Dutch plant-based brands

  • The core twist is that JBS is said to own:
    • Vivera (acquired by JBS in 2021)
    • The Vegetarian Butcher (indirectly owned via a chain: Unilever acquired it in 2018, then sold it to Vivera, which is owned by JBS)
  • The episode claims this ownership is not clearly disclosed on the brands’ websites, despite their “ethical” positioning.

• Contradiction between “plant-based” mission and meat-industry interests

  • The host argues that profits from plant-based sales may ultimately benefit the same actors accused of corruption and exploitation.
  • It also references a failed plant-based venture (Planterra), reportedly shut down by JBS after two years.

• JBS strategy for the future

  • The segment claims JBS expects animal-protein consumption to rise sharply, so it invests heavily in meat infrastructure in places like Asia and Nigeria—as a long-term bet on expanding meat consumption globally.

Overall Conclusion

The segment portrays JBS as a dominant, scandal-ridden meat conglomerate that has absorbed “green”/plant-based brands—making consumers of meat substitutes complicit in the growth of the factory-farming industry these brands originally aimed to challenge.

Presenters / Contributors

• Arjen Lubach (host)
• Greenpeace Netherlands (mentioned as protestors)
• Greenpeace activists (protested at a JBS shareholder meeting)
• Rob Trip / Brazilian television figures (briefly referenced)
• De Marker (journalistic platform referenced)
• Vivera CEO (quoted as refusing to comment)
• Jaap Korteweg (founder of The Vegetarian Butcher referenced)
• Head of Sustainability at Vivera and The Vegetarian Butcher (interviewed by De Marker)
• Jose Batista Sobrinho, Wesley and Joesley Batista (JBS founders/leaders referenced)
• JBS inspectors / Brazilian president / Trump (referenced in scandals and context)