Video summary

How to Implement the 4% Rule

Main summary

Key takeaways

Finance

Implementing the 4% Rule

Rob Berger answers a viewer’s practical questions about withdrawing from a retirement portfolio. In the example, a $1 million portfolio produces a $40,000 first-year withdrawal under the 4% rule. After the first year, the rule generally adjusts that original withdrawal for inflation; it does not recalculate 4% of the portfolio’s current value each year.

Withdrawal framework and options

  • Annual withdrawals: Collect dividends and bond interest in cash, then sell shares if needed to reach the next year’s spending amount. Withdraw the money and rebalance the portfolio to its target allocation. Berger says this is simple and broadly follows the approach assumed by Bill Bengen in his 1994 paper.
  • Quarterly withdrawals: Berger’s preferred cadence. Let dividends and interest accumulate, then sell enough shares each quarter to meet that quarter’s spending needs. Rebalancing could still happen annually.
  • Monthly withdrawals: Also possible, and they keep more cash invested, but Berger considers them more work.

There is no single correct withdrawal frequency. The choice depends on an investor’s preference for simplicity, cash exposure, and administrative effort.

Inflation adjustments

  • For a 2023 withdrawal, Berger says he would be comfortable using the 7.1% CPI increase for the 12 months through November 2022, even though it is not the final calendar-year 2022 figure. The full-year number would be available in early January.
  • As an alternative to CPI, he recommends tracking personal spending to estimate personal inflation, since individual expenses may differ from the CPI basket.
  • The example for 2024 uses $40,800, based on a 2% inflation adjustment to a $40,000 initial withdrawal.

Dividends, interest, reinvestment, and taxes

Stock funds commonly distribute dividends quarterly, while bond funds commonly pay interest monthly. Berger notes that, in his experience, stock-fund distributions often arrive largely in December.

Investors can leave distributions in cash to fund spending or reinvest them and sell shares when needed. The choice can be made account by account. Berger says he would reinvest distributions in accounts he does not expect to use for near-term spending. For taxable accounts, he avoids automatic reinvestment to retain flexibility for rebalancing.

Tax consequences also matter. Investors should consider which accounts to draw from and, in taxable accounts, which investments or shares to sell.

Market declines and cash reserves

  • Bengen’s approach, as described by Berger, is to make the planned withdrawal and rebalance even in weak markets. Rebalancing may mean selling assets that held up relatively well and buying those that fell, consistent with “sell high, buy low.”
  • Berger cautions against building a withdrawal strategy around 2022, when stocks and bonds both fell by double digits—a combination he describes as exceptionally rare, roughly a “one-in-a-hundred-year” event.
  • Holding one or two years of spending in cash may feel reassuring, but cash can weigh on long-term returns and must eventually be replenished from the investment portfolio.
  • Berger says Bengen’s later analysis suggested that cash of up to about 10% could be treated as part of the bond allocation; holding more could negatively affect the safe withdrawal rate.

Assets and instruments mentioned

  • Stocks and bonds
  • Stock and bond ETFs and mutual funds
  • Cash, money-market accounts, and checking accounts
  • Dividends, bond interest, and capital-gains distributions
  • No specific ticker symbols are mentioned

Disclosures and sources

Berger identifies Tiller as an advertiser and says it can import bank and credit-card data into Google Sheets or Microsoft Excel for spending tracking. No explicit “not financial advice” disclaimer appears in the subtitles.

Presenter and sources: Rob Berger; viewer Jeff (question that prompted the discussion); Bill Bengen (4% rule research and later cash-allocation analysis); U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI data; Tiller (advertiser).

Rate this summary

Your feedback will help improve summaries.

Improve this summary

Reprocess with a stronger model when the summary feels incomplete or inaccurate.

Pro

Translate summary in another language

Pro

Ask questions to this video

Chat for follow-up questions, clarifications, and source-backed answers.

Coming soon

Share this summary

Original video