Video summary
The Soulsborne Mindset has Ruined Action Games
Main summary
Key takeaways
Summary
The video argues that the popularity of Soulsborne-style design has shaped expectations for action games, leading many players and reviewers to dismiss other combat systems as “button mashers.” The creator says that a game’s combat can have depth even if it doesn’t require players to use every move. Some games provide tools and expect players to experiment and discover ways to use them.
Key points include:
- Depth can come from player experimentation. The creator points to Bayonetta’s movement, weapon switching, enemy design, Dodge Offset, and bounce mechanics as examples of qualities often overlooked in shallow critiques.
- Complexity and accessibility are different concerns. Dante in Devil May Cry 5 has a large moveset, multiple styles and weapons, and many changing properties. This depth can be exciting, but might overwhelm a newcomer if they had to master it while facing difficult enemies.
- Replayability can take different forms. Action games may introduce enemy types, attacks, or greater aggression at higher difficulties. Their long-term appeal can come from learning the systems and improving as a player. Soulsborne games, by contrast, often invite replay through builds, weapons, challenge runs, and different choices.
- Reviews should account for the full game. The creator criticizes reviewers who judge an action game after only one playthrough, especially when later difficulties and additional challenges may change the experience.
- Players should critique what a game offers, not what they expected it to offer. The creator says it is fine not to enjoy a game’s combat, but labels like “button masher” can reflect a lack of experimentation rather than a lack of depth.
The video uses Final Fantasy XVI as a recent example in discussions of combat, contrasting it with God of War, Bayonetta, and Devil May Cry. It also includes a sponsored segment for Raid: Shadow Legends.
Gamers and Sources Mentioned
- DarkSydePhil (DSP): Referenced in connection with experimenting in The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom.
- Game journalists and reviewers: Discussed generally.
- Otaku, Polygon, IGN, Twitter, and Reddit: Cited as places or audiences that shape opinions about action games.
- Ryota Suzuki: Apparently referenced in the subtitles as the “Devil May Cry guy” who worked on Final Fantasy XVI.
- Raid: Shadow Legends: Featured in the sponsored segment.
Rate this summary
Your feedback will help improve summaries.
Improve this summary
Reprocess with a stronger model when the summary feels incomplete or inaccurate.
Translate summary in another language
Ask questions to this video
Chat for follow-up questions, clarifications, and source-backed answers.