Video summary
Becoming White - Aquarini Priyatna
Main summary
Key takeaways
Summary
Aquarini Priyatna’s lecture examines how soap advertising constructs ideas about race, whiteness, class, femininity, and globalization. Her central argument is that soap is not merely a product for cleaning the body: advertisements use it to sell social ideals and make racial and class hierarchies seem ordinary.
Race, Whiteness, and the Gaze
- Race is not a neutral way of describing people. Naming racial groups is an exercise of power: dominant groups often have the authority to define others while remaining unnamed themselves.
- In many Western racial frameworks, whiteness is treated as the unmarked norm. Race is consequently associated with people who are not white, while white people may not be understood as having a race.
- Race is tied to visibility: skin and physical features are read before a person speaks. But race depends not only on the body; it also depends on who is looking and on the social position of the viewer.
- The dominant group may not notice its own privilege because it is accustomed to looking rather than being scrutinized. The gaze is shaped by colonial histories, gender, sexuality, class, and location.
- Priyatna connects this to her personal experience of wanting male attention and changing her habits in pursuit of a beauty ideal. She describes the physical cost of giving up activities such as swimming to maintain lighter skin, as well as the cost of measuring her body through the male gaze.
Soap as a Technology of Social Purification
Soap cleans literal dirt, but its meaning in advertising extends to social ideas of cleanliness, respectability, and status. Dirt can signify more than physical grime: it may be associated with low-status work, sexual impropriety, or a supposed lack of culture.
Drawing on Anne McClintock, Priyatna describes soap as a vehicle for “commodity racism”: ordinary consumer goods can carry racial and colonial messages. British imperial culture presented soap as part of a “civilizing” mission, in which washing and clothing people represented as savage or uncultured signified progress. Everyday products such as soap, tea, and biscuits could thus reinforce ideas of British cultural superiority.
In this symbolic system, washing can suggest movement from a lower social position to a higher one. Soap advertisements therefore sell fantasies of class mobility as well as hygiene.
Historical Advertising Imagery
Priyatna identifies several recurring visual motifs in soap advertising:
- White clothing: Associated with domestic respectability, cleanliness, purity, and the ability to reveal dirt.
- Mirrors: Represent the gaze and bodily self-scrutiny. Viewers are invited to compare themselves with an ideal and look for flaws.
- Monkeys and hybrids: Monkeys can stand for nature or the supposedly uncultured. In some Victorian imagery, they also substitute for women doing domestic labor—work whose importance was often obscured.
- The hybrid woman: Victorian ideals asked women to be respectable and “ladylike” in public while also being sexually available in private. Priyatna argues that this contradiction continues in modern advertising.
A Pears advertisement from around 1918 shows a Black child apparently transformed by soap into a white child. The image presents whiteness as cultured and desirable, while the mirror suggests that racial transformation is possible. Yet the hierarchy remains intact: the advertisement implies that a change in skin alone does not erase presumed cultural difference.
A 1955 Lux advertisement featuring Susan Hayward makes beauty appear to be an ideal separated from the viewer by a gap. Soap is offered as the means to bridge that gap. Priyatna argues that advertising and consumer culture repeatedly create and exploit distance between people’s actual selves and idealized beauty.
Femininity, Sexuality, and Class
Soap advertising often presents women as both innocent and sexual, even when the same woman embodies both roles.
Priyatna discusses a Tamara Bleszynski advertisement that divides her image into a modest, “girl next door” figure and a more overtly sexual one. The split reflects a broader expectation that women should appear pure and restrained while also being attractive and sexually appealing.
A Giv advertisement featuring Sophia Latjuba presents bathing as a private luxury and an act of self-pampering. Yet her gaze suggests awareness that she is being watched, complicating the idea that the scene is simply for her own enjoyment.
In an advertisement pairing Sophia Latjuba with her daughter, Eva Celia, the contrast in their skin tones reinforces the ideal of lighter skin. The mother’s sexuality is also softened by her association with motherhood, reflecting a social expectation that mothers should not be presented as sexual.
These images also signal class. The polished, understated, “natural” beauty shown in the advertisements is treated as normative, middle-class femininity. “Naturalness” is paradoxical: it can require careful styling and production while being presented as effortless and cultured.
Mixed-Race Identity, Whiteness, and “Passing”
Priyatna focuses on mixed-race, or Indo, celebrities because they occupy an ambiguous position: they may be read as white in a local context but not as white in a global or Western one.
Mixed-race identity is not always easy to name. Questions such as “What are you?” reveal that others cannot readily classify a person’s body. Self-identification can therefore become a political choice rather than a simple description.
The Indo body can be used in Indonesian advertising as a locally recognizable version of whiteness. Photography, lighting, styling, makeup, clothing, and other forms of fabrication help models “pass” as white. This does not mean whiteness is fixed or has a single authentic appearance. If whiteness can be imitated and fabricated, its boundaries are unstable.
Priyatna also notes that mixed-race bodies can be treated as transgressive because they cross categories that racial systems try to keep separate.
Local and Global Advertising
Lux advertisements use celebrities and visual styles associated with glamour and high art, even though soap itself is an everyday, relatively inexpensive product. In Indonesia, Lux has repeatedly used Indo celebrities, including Tamara Bleszynski and Sophia Latjuba, rather than simply importing Western models. Priyatna reads this as a localization of global ideals: the models make whiteness recognizable and desirable in a local context.
She contrasts Lux with Giv, which she describes as imitating aspects of Lux’s style. This imitation is an example of mimicry: local advertising borrows from a global model but adjusts it to local expectations.
Mimicry both acknowledges the authority of the model being copied and unsettles the idea that the model is original or authentic. It can also provoke policing: local images may be criticized when they appear to cross limits that are accepted for global celebrities.
Globalization therefore does not simply erase local differences. Global products and images are adapted, and local expectations shape what forms of beauty or sexuality can be shown.
Magazines and the “Future Self”
Priyatna describes a research approach based on examining women’s magazines and advertisements together, rather than treating each soap advertisement as an isolated image. She studies how advertising interacts with magazine covers, interviews, clothing, colors, and wider ideas of beauty.
Magazine covers can function as a “window to the future self”: viewers imagine that they might become more like the model by changing their bodies, skin, clothes, or habits. Advertising produces both distance and identification. Viewers see that they do not currently look like the ideal, but are also offered products and routines that promise to bring them closer to it.
Soap and beauty products thus sell not only physical results but also an imagined future identity and a middle-class lifestyle.
Main Takeaway
Soap advertising turns everyday hygiene into a story about who is clean, beautiful, cultured, feminine, and socially desirable. Through images of whiteness, idealized bodies, celebrity, and domestic life, it can reproduce colonial and class hierarchies while presenting them as personal choices or ordinary standards of beauty.
Speakers and Sources
Speaker
- Aquarini Priyatna, presenting ideas from her book Becoming White: Representations of Race, Class, Feminism, and Globality in Soap Advertising and her Lancaster dissertation.
Scholars and Concepts Cited
- Richard Dyer — whiteness as an unmarked norm.
- Anne McClintock — soap, imperialism, domesticity, and commodity racism.
- Homi Bhabha — mimicry and the idea of being “almost the same, but not quite.”
- Stuart Hall — globalization and cultural change.
- McCracken — the “future self” associated with magazine images.
Advertisements, Media, Brands, and Public Figures Discussed
The lecture discusses Pears and Monkey Brand soap advertisements; Lux and Giv advertisements; and references to Lifebuoy, Dove, Garnier, Pond’s, Sariayu, and Clear. Women’s magazines include Femina, Cosmopolitan, and Kartini.
Celebrities and models discussed include Halle Berry, Susan Hayward, Widyawati, Marini, Ida Iasha, Marissa, Nadia Vega, Sophia Latjuba, Feby Febiola, Lydia Kandou, Tamara Bleszynski, Eva Celia, Mariana Renata, Dian Sastrowardoyo, Sarah Jessica Parker, Aishwarya Rai, Tamannaah Bhatia, Anggun, Agnes Monica, Nia Ramadhani, and Gisel.
The lecture also briefly refers to McDonald’s and KFC as examples of global brands adapting to local practices. No other identifiable speaker is featured; audience responses are unnamed.
Rate this summary
Your feedback will help improve summaries.
Improve this summary
Reprocess with a stronger model when the summary feels incomplete or inaccurate.
Translate summary in another language
Ask questions to this video
Chat for follow-up questions, clarifications, and source-backed answers.