Video summary
Who Decided Which Books Made It Into the Bible — and What They Cut
Main summary
Key takeaways
Summary
The video argues that the Bible’s contents were not settled by one council, emperor, or vote. Instead, Christian communities gradually converged on a core collection over several centuries. Books were evaluated and received differently across regions, and some writings were read for instruction without being counted as Scripture.
How the canon developed
The Hebrew Scriptures and the “Council of Jamnia”
A popular account says that Jewish leaders met at Jamnia around 90 CE and voted to close the Hebrew scriptural canon. The video explains that the evidence does not support this as a formal council that excluded books. The Mishnah records a debate about whether Song of Songs and Ecclesiastes made the hands “unclean”—a marker of sacred status—not a vote closing the canon.
The date when the Jewish Scriptures were finalized remains debated.
The Septuagint and the early Christian Old Testament
The Hebrew Scriptures were translated into Greek over an extended period, producing the collection known as the Septuagint. Early Christians often used and quoted this Greek text. Its manuscripts included books such as Tobit, Judith, Maccabees, Wisdom, Sirach, and Baruch.
Their use in Greek-speaking churches became important in later disagreements about the Old Testament.
Early disputes over Christian writings
In the second century, Marcion promoted a short collection of 11 books: an edited version of Luke and ten letters of Paul. He rejected the Old Testament. His list helped prompt other Christians to clarify which books they recognized.
The Muratorian Fragment, a damaged and incomplete list, accepts many New Testament books but treats the Shepherd of Hermas as useful reading rather than Scripture, partly because it was too recent to belong to the apostolic age.
Irenaeus defended the use of exactly four Gospels. His surviving argument invokes symbolic patterns—four regions, winds, and faces of the cherubim—while the video suggests that the four Gospels’ established use and claimed apostolic connections were also important.
The boundaries remained unsettled: Irenaeus did not cite every New Testament book, and several books were still disputed in Origen’s time.
Recurring criteria
The video identifies three recurring considerations in early Christian discussions. They were not a single formal rulebook but can be inferred from the arguments and lists:
- Apostolic connection: Was the work believed to come from an apostle or someone close to the apostles?
- Use in worship: Was it read aloud and used by churches, preferably across more than one region?
- Agreement with established belief: Did it fit the faith already held by the churches?
The video also distinguishes a book being disputed from its being forbidden. Some writings circulated and were valued without being accepted everywhere as Scripture.
Lists, councils, and the Nicaea misconception
Around 324–330, Eusebius grouped books into recognized, disputed, and rejected categories. His disputed list included James, Jude, 2 Peter, and 2 and 3 John. His rejected category included the Shepherd of Hermas, the Epistle of Barnabas, and the Didache.
The First Council of Nicaea in 325 addressed matters such as the creed, Easter dating, church discipline, and a dispute within the Egyptian church. The video says no decision about the biblical canon is recorded there.
Constantine’s later commission of 50 Bibles for Constantinople is not evidence of a formal canon-setting order; the contents of those copies are unknown.
In 367, Athanasius’s Easter letter gave the earliest surviving list matching today’s 27-book New Testament. He excluded the Shepherd and the Teaching of the Apostles (the Didache) from the canon while saying they could be read for instruction.
Regional councils and church leaders continued to compare and confirm lists. The video highlights Hippo (393), Carthage (397 and 419), and a letter from Pope Innocent I around 405. It presents this as a gradual process, not a single universal ballot.
Books outside or on the margins
- Codex Sinaiticus: This fourth-century Greek Bible contains the complete New Testament and continues with the Epistle of Barnabas and part of the Shepherd of Hermas. Its contents show that manuscripts could include books beyond the later standard New Testament list.
- The Didache: Mentioned by Eusebius and Athanasius, it was rediscovered in a manuscript in Constantinople in 1873.
- The Nag Hammadi library: Found in Egypt in 1945, it included the only complete copy of the Gospel of Thomas. The reason the books were buried remains uncertain. The video cautions that their discovery does not prove they were banned or that they represented a “real Bible.”
Why Christian Bibles have different book counts
In his German New Testament, Martin Luther moved Hebrews, James, Jude, and Revelation to the end, but did not remove them. He placed seven Old Testament books—including Tobit, Judith, Maccabees, Wisdom, Sirach, and Baruch—in a separate Apocrypha section.
The Council of Trent in 1546 affirmed the Catholic Old Testament collection, including those books, alongside the 27 New Testament books.
The video gives these broad comparisons:
- Catholic: 73 books (46 Old Testament, 27 New Testament).
- Protestant: 66 books (39 Old Testament, 27 New Testament).
- Anglican: An intermediate practice, reading the Apocrypha for instruction but not as a basis for doctrine.
- Eastern and Oriental Orthodox: Collections vary and may include additional books.
- Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo: Described as having narrower and broader canons, roughly 81 and 90 books; the precise enumeration is not settled in a single published compilation.
Overall conclusion
No one person or council is shown to have decided the biblical canon for all Christians. Congregations’ reading practices, bishops’ judgments, regional councils, and later church decisions all played a part.
The word “cut” can be misleading for many books: some were never widely accepted as Scripture, while others remained valued for reading or instruction. The differences among modern Christian Bibles are chiefly about the Old Testament books inherited through Greek Christian tradition, not about the New Testament’s 27 books.
Speakers and sources featured
Voices heard
- An unnamed narrator.
- One unidentified voice in a brief clip, saying that the pages were examined carefully before being photographed.
Historical figures, documents, and institutions discussed or cited
- The Mishnah, Yadayim 3:5; the Septuagint; and the Letter of Aristeas.
- Marcion; the Muratorian Fragment; Irenaeus; Origen; and Eusebius, Church History, Book 3, chapter 25.
- The Council of Nicaea; Athanasius, Festal Letter 39; the Decretum Gelasianum; the synods of Hippo and Carthage; and Pope Innocent I’s letter to Exsuperius.
- Codex Sinaiticus; the Didache; the Nag Hammadi library; and the Gospel of Thomas.
- Martin Luther; the Council of Trent; and the Fetha Nagast.
Scholars named
Heinrich Graetz, W. M. Christie, Jack P. Lewis, Sid Leiman, Metzger, Hill, Sundberg, Rothschild, James Robinson, and Blount.
Rate this summary
Your feedback will help improve summaries.
Improve this summary
Reprocess with a stronger model when the summary feels incomplete or inaccurate.
Translate summary in another language
Ask questions to this video
Chat for follow-up questions, clarifications, and source-backed answers.