Video summary
Who Was Allah Before Islam?
Main summary
Key takeaways
Summary
The video argues that Allah was known in Arabia before Islam. Muhammad did not introduce the name or the idea of a creator god called Allah. Rather, Islam reshaped existing beliefs by insisting that Allah alone should be worshipped and that he would ultimately judge humanity.
1. The Qur’an’s “associators”
The Qur’an describes Muhammad’s opponents as mushrikun, often translated as “pagans” or “polytheists.” The video notes that the term more literally means people who associate others with God.
In the Qur’an’s account, they already recognize Allah as the creator of the heavens and earth, humanity, and rain, but also worship or appeal to other divine beings. These could include lesser deities, angels, or intermediaries.
2. What the word “Allah” means
Most scholars, the video says, trace Allah to the Arabic al-ilah, meaning “the god.” The word is related to older Semitic terms such as El and Elohim. Depending on context, it could mean a god generally or the supreme god above others.
The video points to two examples of this broader usage:
- Arab Christians used al-ilah for the Christian God, including in a 512 CE inscription.
- The Nabataeans could call their chief god Dushara “the god,” despite recognizing many gods.
The name of the goddess Allat may similarly derive from al-ilat, “the goddess,” illustrating how a descriptive phrase could become a fixed divine name.
3. What inscriptions reveal about pre-Islamic Allah
Inscriptions from northern Arabia and nearby regions show Allah used as the name of a particular deity, sometimes alongside other gods. These short texts were often carved by people traveling or living in the desert, rather than being formal temple records.
- Safaitic inscriptions: In a corpus of roughly 50,000 texts, Allah is invoked fewer than 50 times, compared with more than 1,400 invocations of Allat. Allah was therefore known, but not the most frequently invoked deity in this material. People call on him for safety, relief, and rain, sometimes alongside other gods.
- Nabataean evidence: Allah appears in personal names such as Abdallah (“servant of Allah”) and Wahballah (“gift of Allah”). Yet dedications and prayers more often directly invoke other gods, especially Dushara.
- A possible creator inscription: A Safaitic inscription discovered by Ahmad al-Jallad’s team in 2024, in a ritual setting in northeastern Jordan and dated around the turn of the Common Era, is difficult to translate. Across several possible readings, it appears to connect Allah with creation and bringing light into the world. This interpretation is suggestive, not certain.
Another Safaitic text calls Allah “the living.” The video notes that this may echo biblical language, though al-Jallad argues similar ideas could also arise from a shared ancient Near Eastern understanding of creation. The Arabic root associated with “create” can carry the sense of dividing or separating, recalling creation narratives in which light is separated from darkness.
4. Pre-Islamic poetry
Pre-Islamic Arabic poetry also portrays Allah as a creator, a giver of rain, and a god people can call on in trouble. This broadly resembles the evidence from inscriptions and the Qur’an’s descriptions of what the mushrikun believed.
The poetry requires caution: it was preserved in collections compiled after Islam, so some lines may have been edited or influenced by later beliefs. Nevertheless, scholars cited in the video consider it useful evidence when interpreted carefully. The poems also complicate the idea that Allah was merely a distant, inactive high god: they depict him as involved in people’s lives.
5. A changing religious landscape
The video suggests that Allah may have become more prominent in the centuries before Islam, amid a wider trend toward emphasizing one supreme god. Similar ideas appeared in Greek and Roman thought, where some philosophers treated the many gods as expressions or manifestations of a single high god.
Arabian communities were connected to the Roman and Persian worlds and to Jewish and Christian communities, making religious exchange possible. In this setting, Allah could have been understood across religious boundaries: Christians could identify him with the biblical God, while some pagans could understand him as a supreme creator above other divine beings.
6. Continuity and change in Islam
The video presents the Qur’anic conflict as not primarily a dispute over whether Allah existed. Rather, the Qur’an challenges the worship of other beings alongside him and rejects the use of intermediaries. It also places strong emphasis on resurrection, final judgment, and ultimate reward or punishment—ideas the video says were not prominent in the pre-Islamic poetry and descriptions of the mushrikun discussed here.
Overall: Pre-Islamic evidence suggests that Allah was already known as a deity, sometimes associated with creation, rain, protection, and life. His prominence and precise role varied across communities. Islam’s distinctive move, as presented in the video, was to make exclusive worship of Allah central and to emphasize his role as humanity’s final judge.
Speakers and sources featured
Speakers and scholars
- Video narrator: The presenter for Religion for Breakfast; not named in the subtitles.
- Dr. Ahmad al-Jallad: Scholar whose team surveyed Safaitic inscriptions and documented the possible creator-and-light inscription.
- Nicolai Sinai: Scholar quoted on the meaning and changing prominence of Allah.
- Patricia Crone: Scholar quoted on the Qur’anic mushrikun and their relationship to Allah and intermediary beings.
- Dr. Patrick D’Silva: Identified in the closing promotion as a Sufism specialist and host of the advertised reading group.
Texts and evidence discussed
- The Qur’an, including its descriptions of the mushrikun, Allah as creator, and the rejection of divine offspring and intermediaries.
- Genesis, especially the account of separating light from darkness.
- Pre-Islamic Safaitic inscriptions, including prayers for safety, relief, and rain, as well as the inscription tentatively linking Allah with light and creation.
- Nabataean inscriptions and theophoric personal names containing Allah.
- A 512 CE Arabic Christian inscription from a martyr shrine in northern Syria.
- Other short pre-Islamic Arabian inscriptions invoking Allah alongside other deities.
- Pre-Islamic Arabic poetry, preserved in later Islamic-era collections.
- Herodotus, cited regarding the name Allilat.
- Dio Chrysostom, Maximus of Tyre, and Macrobius, cited as examples of ideas about a single high god within Greco-Roman religious thought.
Rate this summary
Your feedback will help improve summaries.
Improve this summary
Reprocess with a stronger model when the summary feels incomplete or inaccurate.
Translate summary in another language
Ask questions to this video
Chat for follow-up questions, clarifications, and source-backed answers.