Video summary
He Did His Own Brakes… And Made A HUGE Mistake!
Main summary
Key takeaways
Main Issue and Repair
The video follows a 2016 Audi SQ5 whose owner had replaced the brakes. Afterward, the pedal went nearly to the floor, and the car barely stopped.
The main issue was that the front rotors were too small. The pads were not properly supported by the rotors and could deflect under braking, contributing to the poor pedal feel. The shop compared and measured the parts: the incorrect rotor was about 345 mm, while the correct setup required a much larger 380 mm rotor.
The owner’s pads were also badly and unevenly worn. The shop noted that this could indicate a sticking caliper or slide, although they could not confirm which side was affected.
After installing the correct rotors and pads and cleaning the brake components, the pedal felt firm and normal. Follow-up brake temperatures were similar on both sides—roughly 157–169 degrees—with no clear temperature imbalance.
Parts and Comparisons
The owner had sourced parts through O’Reilly’s. The technicians explained that parts catalogs may show a plausible-looking rotor without making it clear that the vehicle can have several brake sizes.
The shop compared options from different suppliers and brands, including Brembo, Textar, Akebono, and VNE. The correct, larger rotors were substantially more expensive; the video cites $344 for the available VNE rotor.
The shop emphasized that rotor size and design matter, not just price. The Akebono pads shown were correct for the larger rotor, while the pads removed from the car were compatible with the smaller, incorrect setup.
The shop said the owner could return the wrongly purchased parts for a refund, but the correct repair would cost more.
Pros, Cons, and Practical Advice
- Positive outcome: Correcting the rotor size restored a normal, firm brake pedal.
- Downside: The wrong parts caused extra work and expense, and the worn pads had to be replaced.
- Advice: Compare every new part directly with the old one before installation. Check rotor dimensions and pad fit, and investigate uneven pad wear rather than assuming the brakes are otherwise fine.
No numerical product rating was given.
Overall Verdict
This is a cautionary repair story rather than a conventional product review. The key lesson is to verify the exact brake configuration before buying parts: a rotor that appears to fit the vehicle listing may still be the wrong size. The correct rotor and pad combination restored normal braking, though possible caliper or slide issues were noted for further attention.
Different Perspectives
- The lead technician focused on the undersized rotor as the cause of the poor pedal and demonstrated the parts comparison.
- Other shop staff helped check parts availability, measure the rotors, and inspect the uneven pad wear.
- The owner reported that the car barely stopped and required unusually hard pedal pressure.
Rate this summary
Your feedback will help improve summaries.
Improve this summary
Reprocess with a stronger model when the summary feels incomplete or inaccurate.
Translate summary in another language
Ask questions to this video
Chat for follow-up questions, clarifications, and source-backed answers.