Video summary
The Toyota D4D Engine Sucks.
Main summary
Key takeaways
Toyota D-4D Engine Review
Key Findings
- The engine is from a 2007 vehicle that has covered about 480,000 km. It was used for demanding work, including firefighting duties and towing.
- The engine failed with heavy smoke and a cracked piston—a failure the reviewers say is common for this engine. They mention reports of piston failures at around 120,000 (the subtitles are unclear about the units), as well as Toyota service bulletins and online groups devoted to the issue.
- Teardown revealed a large hole in one piston. Its markings showed it was 0.040-inch oversize, indicating the engine had already been rebuilt with replacement pistons. The reviewers suspect this was its second set, yet it failed again.
- The engine apparently covered roughly 200,000 km since the owner acquired it, though gaps in the service history make its earlier history uncertain. The reviewers had not confirmed whether the block was from the original engine.
- A small amount of metal debris was found, though much of what came out appeared to be silicone or other material. The engine had been running roughly, seemingly on three cylinders.
- The reviewers warn against long-distance, high-speed driving under heavy load in hot weather—conditions that matched how the vehicle had been used.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- It reached 480,000 km, an unusually long life for an engine the reviewers consider prone to piston failure.
- The owner reportedly serviced it meticulously, which the reviewers think may have helped it last as long as it did.
Cons
- The central criticism is serious: pistons can crack, and replacement pistons may fail again.
- Diagnosing and dismantling the engine is labor-intensive. Access is awkward, with many hoses and covers to remove; even setting up a compression test through the glow-plug holes required special equipment.
- The reviewers criticize the plastic covers and the engine’s general packaging and serviceability.
Comparisons and Context
- The reviewers contrast diesel combustion chambers with those of petrol engines: diesels typically have a flatter head and rely on very high compression, while this engine’s piston has shaped recesses that form the combustion chamber.
- Their broader view is that Toyota makes reliable, “boring” engines, but that its more interesting or powerful engines can be much less dependable. This is the reviewers’ opinion, not a general finding established by the teardown.
Verdict
The video portrays the D-4D as a high-risk engine because of recurring cracked-piston failures, even after a rebuild. Its 480,000 km run is impressive, but the engine had already been rebuilt and has now failed again. The reviewers leave open whether it is worth repairing, noting that comparable vehicles may still sell for around $14,000.
Different Views in the Video
- One reviewer initially suspects a cracked piston but wants more evidence; James is initially convinced it is not a piston problem. The teardown confirms the piston failure.
- The owner’s careful servicing is credited with helping the engine last, while the reviewers still judge the engine itself to be fundamentally poor.
Rate this summary
Your feedback will help improve summaries.
Improve this summary
Reprocess with a stronger model when the summary feels incomplete or inaccurate.
Translate summary in another language
Ask questions to this video
Chat for follow-up questions, clarifications, and source-backed answers.