Video summary

Ask Autocar Anything - 3 cylinder engines, JSW Combat, Baleno vs Glanza | AAA Ep. 11 | Autocar India

Main summary

Key takeaways

Product Review

Key Points

Three-Cylinder Engines

  • Carmakers are adopting three-cylinder engines partly to improve efficiency. In theory, they may also require less maintenance because they have one fewer cylinder.
  • The panel said cylinder count alone is not a reason to reject a car. Three-cylinder engines can have a distinctive thrum that adds character, and some turbocharged examples are particularly good. The Citroën 1.2 turbo and VW 1.0 TSI were cited.
  • Four-cylinder engines can be smoother. The Maruti K-series and Honda four-cylinders were mentioned as examples. The panel felt that online criticism of three-cylinder engines is often exaggerated.
  • The BMW X1’s 1.5-litre three-cylinder was considered underwhelming. The criticism was less about its cylinder count and more about its lack of punch for a BMW, especially at its price point. One speaker felt the difference in character between four and six cylinders is more significant than the difference between three and four.

JSW Combat

  • The panel expected the high-spec plug-in hybrid to cost around ₹40 lakh. It was described as having bold, mini-Defender-like styling.
  • The vehicle is based on a Chery product sold internationally as the Jetour T2. Early examples are expected to be largely imported, with local assembly and product changes still to come.
  • The panel did not identify a major product-quality concern, but cautioned that JSW is a new car brand in India. Its retail and service network, local assembly process, and customer experience will have a learning curve. Buyers should not expect the established, predictable experience of a brand such as Toyota.
  • A reported concern from testing in Dubai was that the air-conditioning might not be strong enough in extreme heat. The panel said JSW should address this for India, though the extent of possible changes may depend on how directly the vehicle is brought over.

MG Hector Tomahawk: EV or Plug-In Hybrid?

  • For a buyer driving around 1,500 km a month, mostly in town, the EV was considered adequate for regular use.
  • A 400–500 km road trip would bring the EV closer to its limits. Actual range depends on driving style and terrain; hills or inclines could mean needing a charging stop. One speaker thought 400-plus km should be achievable with careful driving.
  • The plug-in hybrid costs roughly ₹5 lakh more. The panel cautioned that buyers may overestimate how much they drive and said the PHEV will not make financial sense for everyone.
  • Overall, the panel recommended the EV for this buyer, with a fast-charger top-up on an occasional long trip if needed.
  • There is no need to wait for the battery to reach 100%. Charging from 80% to 100% is especially slow, so a sufficient top-up to reach the destination is more practical.

Skoda Kushaq 1.5 Versus Alternatives for City Driving

  • The Kushaq 1.5 was described as quick, but its DSG was considered less suited to heavy city traffic. The panel said heating concerns are mostly addressed in newer versions, but city use remains a reason to consider other options.
  • The Kushaq 1.0 with its eight-speed torque-converter automatic was suggested as a more traffic-friendly alternative.
  • The Renault Duster 1.3 with a six-speed wet-clutch DCT was also recommended for consideration. The wet-clutch transmission was described as smooth, and the Duster was praised for its dynamic ability and slight edge in ride comfort.
  • The Duster has a cramped rear seat; the Kushaq was also said not to be especially spacious.
  • The Kushaq 1.5 is quicker and was said to have a broader spread of power delivery. The Duster 1.3 may have more power on paper, but has some turbo lag. The Duster was framed as a good option for someone who enjoys driving.

Maruti Baleno Versus Toyota Glanza

  • The panel said the two cars are fundamentally the same: they are made in the same factory on the same production line, with no meaningful difference in construction or driving feel.
  • Claims that the Glanza is safer or has different sheet metal were dismissed. There could be small aerodynamic differences from the front styling, but no substantial sheet-metal changes were identified.
  • The practical differences mentioned were warranty terms and interior colour themes. Otherwise, the badge is the main distinction and can shape buyers’ perceptions.

Overall Verdict

The panel generally advised judging these cars by actual use and ownership needs rather than assumptions. A three-cylinder engine is not automatically a drawback; the Combat’s main uncertainty is JSW’s new service and retail setup; the EV suits the mostly urban Hector Tomahawk buyer despite occasional long trips; and the Baleno and Glanza are mechanically equivalent.

Different Views and Contributions

  • On three-cylinder engines, the panel was broadly positive, while noting that buyers paying a premium for a BMW may reasonably expect more performance and character from the X1’s engine.
  • On the Tomahawk, one concern was that a 500 km trip could push the EV’s range. The panel’s eventual recommendation was still the EV, given the buyer’s mostly urban driving and the PHEV’s higher price.
  • On the Combat, the panel saw no clear reason to doubt the underlying product, but emphasized that JSW’s service network and local operations remain unproven.

Rate this summary

Your feedback will help improve summaries.

Improve this summary

Reprocess with a stronger model when the summary feels incomplete or inaccurate.

Pro

Translate summary in another language

Pro

Ask questions to this video

Chat for follow-up questions, clarifications, and source-backed answers.

Coming soon

Share this summary

Original video